establish clear standards that provide guidance to the States Parties when defining the delicate limits of this criminal liability in the rare situations in which a clash of precisely substantiated rights may justify a stronger State response. However, for the purposes of this case, the rulings of the judgment and the concurring opinions will not only provide an adequate solution, but will provide a valuable basis for institutional dialogue with the State Party to improve its practices pursuant to the Convention, to which it sovereignly acceded, in a clear international commitment to the preservation of human rights. Rodrigo Mudrovitsch Judge Pablo Saavedra Alessandri