2
11.
The State must implement, within a reasonable time, permanent programs of
human rights training in the Paraguayan police forces, at all levels, in the terms of
paragraph 178 of the judgment.
12.
The State must adapt, within a reasonable time, the definition of the crimes of
torture and “involuntary” (forzosa) disappearance of persons contained in Articles 236
and 309 of the current Penal Code to the applicable provisions of international human
rights law, in the terms of paragraph 179 of the judgment.
13.
The State must pay in cash to the next of kin of Agustín Goiburú Giménez,
Carlos José Mancuello, Rodolfo Ramírez Villalba and Benjamín Ramírez Villalba, within
one year, as compensation for pecuniary damage, the amounts established in paragraph
155 of […] judgment, in the terms of paragraphs 147 and 149 thereof.
14.
The State must pay in cash to Agustín Goiburú Giménez, Carlos José Mancuello
Bareiro, Rodolfo Ramírez Villalba, Benjamín Ramírez Villalba, Elva Elisa Benítez Feliú de
Goiburú, Rogelio Agustín Goiburú Benítez, Rolando Agustín Goiburú Benítez, Patricia
Jazmín Goiburú Benítez, Rosa Mujica Giménez, Gladis Ester Ríos de Mancuello, Claudia
Anahí Mancuello Ríos, Carlos Marcelo Mancuello Ríos, Ana Arminda Bareiro de Mancuello,
Mario Mancuello, Ana Elizabeth Mancuello Bareiro, Hugo Alberto Mancuello Bareiro, Mario
Andrés Mancuello Bareiro, Emilio Raúl Mancuello Bareiro, Fabriciana Villalba de Ramírez,
Lucrecia Ramírez de Borba, Eugenia Adolfina Ramírez de Espinoza, Sotera Ramírez de
Arce, Sara Diodora Ramírez Villalba, Mario Artemio Ramírez Villalba, Herminio Arnoldo
Ramírez Villalba, Julio Darío Ramírez Villalba and María Magdalena Galeano, within one
year, as compensation for non-pecuniary damage, the amounts established in paragraph
161 of this judgment, in the terms of paragraphs 147 to 149 and 162 thereof.
15.
The State must pay in cash, within one year, for costs and expenses incurred in
the domestic sphere and in the international proceedings before the inter-American
system for the protection of human rights, the amount established in paragraph 183 of
this judgment, which shall be delivered to Elva Elisa Benítez Feliú de Goiburú, Ana
Arminda Bareiro de Mancuello and Julio Darío Ramírez Villalba, in the terms of
paragraphs 183 and 187 thereof.
16.
It will monitor full compliance with [the] judgment and will consider the case
closed when the State has fully executed the operative paragraphs. Within a year of
notification of [the] judgment, the State must send the Court a report on the measures
adopted to comply with it.
2.
The State’s brief of August 16, 2007, by which it forwarded a publication of
the Judgment made on May 11, 2007 in the Official Gazette of the Republic of
Paraguay.
3.
The note of the Court’s Secretariat (hereinafter, the “Secretariat”) of August
24, 2007 by which the parties were recalled that, according to the operative
paragraph sixteen of the Judgment, the State must send the Court a report on the
measures adopted to comply with it, within one year of notification of such
Judgment, and therefore the parties will be able to submit their observations once
the report is received.
4.
The brief of October 16, 2007 and its appendixes received on November 6 of
that same year, whereby the State submitted its first report on the measures
adopted to comply with the Judgment.
5.
The Secretariat’s note of October 23, 2007 by which the representatives of
the victims’ next-of-kin (hereinafter, the “representatives”) and the Inter-American
Commission on Human Rights (hereinafter, the “Commission”) were called upon to
submit, within four and six weeks, respectively, their observations to the first State's
report and State's brief of August 16, 2007 (supra Having Seen clause 2).