was able to reunite with this child and that, subsequently, when they left the PTJ, no measures
were taken to place these minors in the custody of a family member or of a state institution.306
217. Based on the above, the Court finds that the State violated the right to personal liberty
established in Articles 7(1), (2) and (3), and 19 of the American Convention to the detriment of
Alexis Valencia Alarcón and Mauricio Valenzuela Valencia, as well as the violation of Articles 7(4)
and 19 of the American Convention to the detriment of Mauricio Valenzuela Valencia.
218. In addition, regarding the allegations of ill-treatment and abuse, Alexis Valencia Alarcón
recounted that, during the raid, and when he was in the patrol vehicle, he was hit on the head
with machine gun butts, he was insulted, and told that his father was a crook.307 During the public
hearing, Mauricio Valenzuela Valencia stated that during the raid the police beat him and pressed
his head against the floor until he passed out.308
219. These acts, executed intentionally, inflicted serious physical and mental suffering on the
alleged victims who were children at the time of the events. Therefore, the Court finds that Alexis
Valencia Alarcón and Mauricio Valenzuela Valencia were victims of cruel and degrading treatment
at the hands of the police. Regarding Claudio Centeno Valencia, another child who is a party to
these proceedings, there is no evidence that the police committed acts of violence against him.
Consequently, the Court concludes that the State violated Articles 5(1), 5(2) and 19 of the
American Convention to the detriment of Alexis Valencia Alarcón and Mauricio Valenzuela Valencia.
220. It is therefore clear that, in light of the aforementioned provisions, in this specific case the
state agents did not respect their enhanced obligation to protect the children who were present
at the time of the raids and that, to the contrary, they committed acts that violated their rights
and, in the case of Claudio Centeno Valencia, they failed to guarantee a minimum of protection
for a 3-year-old child, by not ensuring that he was placed under the care and protection of a family
member or a state institution. Consequently, the Court finds that the State violated Article 19 of
the American Convention to the detriment of Alexis Valencia Alarcón, Mauricio Valenzuela Valencia
and Claudio Centeno Valencia.
VIII-4
RIGHT TO LIFE309 OF GENARO AHUACHO LUNA
A. Arguments of the parties and of the Commission
221. The Commission indicated that Genaro Ahuacho Luna (Walter Herrera Flores or Walter
Herrera Ríos), died while imprisoned in the Chonchocoro Prison. It recalled that the State is
responsible for ensuring respect for the life of all those in its custody and that there is no record
that the State provided him with medical attention, nor has it offered a satisfactory or convincing
explanation for what occurred. Therefore, it is responsible for violating his right to life.
222. The inter-American public defenders alleged that Genaro Ahuacho Luna was subjected
to severe physical and mental ill-treatment during his detention and that he died while confined
in the Chonchocoro Prison. They indicated that there had been a delay in providing him with
adequate medical care when he suffered a stroke. They added that the State had not provided a
satisfactory explanation for what happened and therefore considered that it had violated Article 4
306
Cf. Affidavit made by Alexis Eduardo Valencia Alarcón on June 14, 2022 (evidence file, folios 12620 and 12621).
307
Cf. Affidavit made by Alexis Eduardo Valencia Alarcón on June 14, 2022 (evidence file, folio 12620).
308
Cf. Statement made by Mauricio Valenzuela Valencia during the public hearing on June 21, 2022.
309
Article 4(1) of the American Convention.
62
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos