of the Convention, in relation to Article 1(1) of this instrument, to the detriment of Genaro Ahuacho
Luna.
223. The State argued that it had not deprived the alleged victim of his life; rather it had taken
the appropriate measures to protect and preserve his health while he was deprived of liberty. It
stressed that Mr. Ahuacho Luna died in hospital and not in the prison. It alleged that there was
no evidence whatsoever that would have allowed the State to know Mr. Ahuacho Luna’s health
problems because they were due to high blood pressure, smoking, diabetes, alcohol intake and
lipid profile. It therefore concluded that there was no evidentiary element proving that the death
of Mr. Ahuacho Luna was due to the use of force by state agents; rather the cause of death was
a stroke suffered on April 12, 2004, owing to which the State had activated all the appropriate
mechanisms to protect and preserve his health.
B. Considerations of the Court
224. This Court has already indicated that the State, in its capacity as guarantor of the rights
recognized in the Convention, is responsible for ensuring the right to personal integrity of every
individual in its custody.310 Therefore, the Court reiterates that, as the entity responsible for
detention centers and prisons, the State has the duty to safeguard the health and well-being of
persons deprived of liberty, and to guarantee that the manner and method of deprivation of liberty
does not exceed the inevitable level of suffering inherent in incarceration.311 Thus, a presumption
exists that the State is responsible for any injuries suffered by a person who has been in the
custody of state agents,312 and the State has the obligation to provide a satisfactory and
convincing explanation of what happened and to refute the allegations of its responsibility with
satisfactory probative elements.313
225. First, the Court notes that, in the instant case, it has already been determined that Genaro
Ahuacho Luna was a victim of cruel and degrading treatment during the raid of the house located
at No. 2525 Presbítero Merina and his detention in the PTJ facilities (supra paras. 175 and 204).
Even though he had visible injuries, as revealed by the video of the PTJ police operation (supra
para. 62), he was not examined by a forensic physician when he arrived at the PTJ. On April 12,
2002, while in the Chonchocoro Prison, he suffered a loss of consciousness. The prison doctor
indicated that he should be transferred to a hospital; however, this transfer only occurred four
hours later. Finally, Genaro Ahuacho Luna died on April 14, 2002, in the Corazón de Jesús Hospital
as the result of a cerebrovascular accident involving the middle left cerebral artery, and respiratory
failure.
226. The State argued that there was no evidence that permitted Mr. Ahuacho Luna’s death to
be linked to an action by the State and that it was due to pre-existing conditions. However, it can
be observed that the alleged victim did not receive medical attention on entering the detention
center and, therefore, there is no way of verifying the extent of the injuries resulting from the illtreatment he suffered and its possible aftereffects. Furthermore, it has been proved that the state
Cf. Case of Juan Humberto Sánchez v. Honduras, supra, para. 99, and Case of Guachalá Chimbo et al. v.
Ecuador. Merits, reparations and costs. Judgment of March 26, 2021. Series C No. 426, para. 151.
310
311
Cf. Case of the “Juvenile Re-education Institute” v. Paraguay, supra, para. 159, and Case of Montesinos Mejía
v. Ecuador. Preliminary objections, merits, reparations and costs. Judgment of January 27, 2020. Series C No. 398,
para. 150.
Cf. Case of the “Street Children” (Villagrán Morales et al.) v. Guatemala. Merits, supra, paras. 95 and 170, and
Case of Guachalá Chimbo et al. v. Ecuador, supra, para. 163.
312
313
Cf. Case of Montero Aranguren et al. (Retén de Catia) v. Venezuela. Preliminary objection, merits, reparations
and costs. Judgment of July 5, 2006. Series C No. 150, para. 80, and Case of Guachalá Chimbo et al. v. Ecuador,
supra, para. 163.
63
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos