but released in the course of the investigation. Therefore, the Commission considered that the
presumption of innocence had also been violated.
246. The inter-American public defenders considered that the public exhibition of the alleged
victims by the police was a violation of the right to the presumption of innocence. They underlined
that those arrested during the raids were presented at a press conference, and individuals who
were not even suspects were present. They considered that the attacks in the press were fostered
by the State and created a stigmatizing effect. Regarding the right of defense, they stressed that
the suspects were held for more than 60 days in solitary confinement and this prevented access
to their defense lawyers; moreover, initially, they were even prohibited from choosing their own
lawyer, and the assistance of an official public defender was imposed on them. They also argued
that the defense counsel did not act with due diligence because, on learning of the acts of torture,
they either did nothing in this regard or merely reported it without taking any action in response
to the indifference of the judges. Therefore, they considered that the State had violated the right
to be heard with due guarantees, and the right of defense guaranteed by Article 8(1), 8(2)(d) and
8(2)(e) of the Convention.
247. Regarding the enhanced duty to investigate torture, they argued that, during the hearing
on precautionary measures, at least two of the public defenders who intervened argued that those
who had been detained had suffered ill-treatment. However, the investigating judge failed to take
any measure in this regard. Subsequently, when delivering the judgment convicting the
defendants, the judge once again ignored the allegations of their torture and ill-treatment. He
merely ordered that the case file be forwarded to the Public Prosecution Service for an
investigation to be opened into acts committed by public officials that violated human rights;
however, they indicated that they were unaware of the result of this process. It was not until
2010, after the Inter-American Commission had issued its Admissibility Report in this case that
an investigation was opened, ex officio. Several irregularities occurred during this process in
relation to time frames and the way in which statements were taken, and it was not until 10 years
later that one suspect was formally indicted. Consequently, they considered that the investigation
had not complied with the standards of due diligence. In conclusion they argued that the State
had violated the right to judicial protection and its duty of due diligence when investigating torture
and cruel treatment arising from Articles 8(1) and 25 of the Convention and Articles 1, 6 and 8 of
the ICPPT. They added that, since the acts of sexual violence against the women alleged victims
had not been investigated diligently, Article 7(b) of the Convention of Belem do Pará had also
been violated.
248. Representative Jemio Mendoza argued that María Fernanda Peña Gallardo should also
have been included in the proceedings initiated in 2010 for the crimes of ill-treatment and torture,
as a victim of those crimes, owing to the mental torture suffered; however, her name was not
included among the victims in the investigation conducted under case file No. 6147/2010. He also
argued that neither her family nor her legal representative had been informed of the procedural
status of that case. Therefore, he considered that the enhanced duty to investigate torture and
the need for due diligence and a gender perspective in cases of violence against women had been
violated..
249. Representative Gómez Rojas argued that gross human rights violations had occurred in
this case and, therefore, the State had an enhanced obligation to investigate, prosecute and
punish all those responsible, including the superior officers. He considered that, during the raids,
and subsequently in the Judicial Technical Police facilities, police agents acting in coordination,
under the command of their superior officers, committed acts of violence, rape, and torture in a
public, massive and reiterated way, without their superiors intervening to prevent or avoid such
acts. Therefore, he considered that, to comply with the established standards for an investigation,
69
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos