254. Article 8(2) of the Convention stipulates that “[e]very person accused of a criminal offense
has the right to be presumed innocent so long as his guilt has not been proven according to law,”
and this is one of the basic tenets of judicial guarantees.340 The presumption of innocence signifies,
among other matters,341 that the State must not condemn an individual informally, or issue an
opinion publicly, thereby contributing to form public opinion, while a person’s criminal
responsibility has not been legally proven. Consequently, this right can be violated by both the
judge in charge of the proceedings, and other public authorities; therefore, before an individual
has been tried and convicted, they should be discreet and prudent when making public statements
concerning criminal proceedings.342
255. In addition, Article 11 of the Convention establishes that “everyone has the right to have
his honor protected and his dignity recognized.” The Court has indicated that the right to honor
recognizes that everyone has the right to have his honor respected and his dignity recognized,
and that no one may be the object of unlawful attacks on his honor or reputation; also, it imposes
on States the duty to provide legal protection against such attacks. In general, the Court has
indicated that the right to honor relates to self-esteem and self-worth, whereas reputation refers
to the opinion that others have of a person.343 The Court has declared that this right has been
violated in cases in which it was proved that the State had subjected a person or group of persons
to hate, stigmatization, public contempt, persecution or discrimination owing to public statements
by public officials.344
256. The facts of the case reveal that, on December 19, 2001, the Executive Branch ordered that
a press conference be held in the offices of the Ministry of the Interior, in which the following
alleged victims were presented to the media as those responsible for the robbery: Blas Valencia
Campos, Norma Alarcón de Valencia, Gabriel Valencia Alarcón, Claudia Valencia Alarcón, Edwin
Rodríguez Alarcón, Luis Fernando Lulleman Gutiérrez, Oswaldo Lulleman Antezana, Victoria
Gutiérrez de Lulleman, Jenny Paola Lulleman de Zaconeta, Víctor Boggiano, Elacio Peña Córdova,
Genaro Ahuacho, Alfredo Bazán y Rosas, Mercedes Valencia Chuquimia, Julia Mamanu Mamani,
F.E.P.M., Eladio Cruz Añez, Carlos Enrique Castro Ramírez, Patricia Gallardo, Mauricio Valenzuela
and Freddy Cáceres.345 Pictures of this conference were published by several media outlets (supra
Cf. Case of Suárez Rosero v. Ecuador. Merits. Judgment of November 12, 1997. Series C No. 35, para. 77, and
Case of Habbal et al. v. Argentina. Preliminary objections and merits. Judgment of August 31, 2022. Series C No. 463,
para. 95.
340
Presumption of innocence means that the defendant does not have to prove that he has not committed the
offense of which he is accused because the onus probandi is on the accuser (Cf. Case of Ricardo Canese v. Paraguay.
Merits, reparations and costs. Judgment of August 31, 2004. Series C No. 111, para. 154, and Case of Manuela et al.
v. El Salvador, supra, para. 132) and any doubt should be used to the benefit of the defendant. Solid evidence of
guilt is an essential requirement for a criminal conviction, and therefore the burden of proof falls on the plaintiff and
not on the defendant (Cf. Case of Zegarra Marín v. Peru. Preliminary objections, merits, reparations and costs.
Judgment of February 15, 2017. Series C No. 331, para. 123, and Case of Manuela et al. v. El Salvador, supra, para.
132). Furthermore, the principle of the presumption of innocence means that judges may not initiate proceedings
with a preconceived idea that the defendant has committed the offense of which he is accused (Cf. Case of Cabrera
García and Montiel Flores v. Mexico. Preliminary objection, merits, reparations and costs. Judgment of November 26,
2010. Series C No. 220. para. 184, and Case of Manuela et al. v. El Salvador, supra, para. 132).
341
Cf. Case of Pollo Rivera et al. v. Peru, supra, para. 177, and Case of Acosta et al. v. Nicaragua. Preliminary
objections, merits, reparations and costs. Judgment of March 25, 2017. Series C No. 334, para. 190.
342
343
Case of Tristán Donoso v. Panama. Preliminary objection, merits, reparations and costs. Judgment of January
27, 2009. Series C No. 193, para. 57, and Case of Palacio Urrutia et al. v. Ecuador, supra, para. 101.
Cf. Case of the Santo Domingo Massacre v. Colombia. Preliminary objections, merits and reparations. Judgment
of November 30, 2012. Series C No. 259, para. 286, and Case of Andrade Salmón v. Bolivia, supra, para. 183.
344
In the case of Carlos Álvaro Taboada Valencia, although he indicated that, following his arrest, he was presented
to the media in Cochabamba, no evidence was presented that verified the press conference or the publication of his
photograph in the media.
345
71
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos