B.1.4) The warnings or threats so that the presumed victims would not testify about what happened ................... 135 B.1.5) The psychological appraisals of the presumed victims and the reports .................................................... 136 B.1.6) Conclusion as regards what happened to Orlando Quijano and José Vicente Rubiano Galvis ....................... 137 B.2) Right to personal liberty .......................................................................................................................... 138 B.2.1) Deprivation of liberty of Yolanda Santodomingo Albericci, Eduardo Matson Ospino and Orlando Quijano .................................................................................................................................................. 139 B.2.2) Deprivation of liberty of José Vicente Rubiano Galvis ............................................................................ 143 B.3) Prohibition of torture and other forms of cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment.............................................. 145 XI. RIGHTS TO JUDICIAL GUARANTEES AND TO JUDICIAL PROTECTION IN RELATION TO THE OBLIGATION TO RESPECT AND TO ENSURE RIGHTS .............................................................................................. 150 A. Arguments of the parties and of the Commission ................................................................................................... 151 B. Considerations of the Court ................................................................................................................................. 152 B.1) Investigations in the military criminal jurisdiction ........................................................................................ 154 B.2) Detention of those presumed responsible in military facilities ........................................................................ 159 B.2.1) Relevant facts for the analysis of the obligation to investigate, prosecute and duly punish those presumed responsible, and their place of detention ....................................................................................... 159 B.2.2) Considerations of the Court on the obligation to investigate, prosecute and duly punish those presumed responsible, and their place of detention ....................................................................................... 162 B.3) Absence of an investigation ex officio ........................................................................................................ 165 B.4) Failure to search for the disappeared victims .............................................................................................. 167 B.5) Due diligence ........................................................................................................................................ 169 B.5.1) Due diligence in the initial investigation measures ............................................................................... 170 B.5.2) Due diligence in the ordinary jurisdiction ............................................................................................ 175 B.6) Reasonable time of the proceedings in the ordinary criminal jurisdiction ......................................................... 177 B.7) Right to know the truth ........................................................................................................................... 178 B.8) General conclusion ................................................................................................................................. 180 XII. OBLIGATION TO PREVENT VIOLATIONS OF THE RIGHTS TO LIFE AND TO PERSONAL INTEGRITY ............... 180 A. Arguments of the parties and of the Commission ................................................................................................... 181 B. Considerations of the Court ................................................................................................................................. 182 XIII. RIGHT TO PERSONAL INTEGRITY OF THE NEXT OF KIN OF THE PERSONS DISAPPEARED, DETAINED AND TORTURED ..................................................................................................................................... 188 A. Arguments of the Commission and of the parties ................................................................................................... 189 B. Considerations of the Court ................................................................................................................................. 189 XIV. REPARATIONS ................................................................................................................................................ 196 A. Injured party ..................................................................................................................................................... 196 B. Preliminary considerations on reparations ............................................................................................................. 197 B.1) Remedies available in the contentious-administrative jurisdiction .................................................................. 197 B.2) Other measures of reparation available in the domestic sphere ..................................................................... 198 C. Obligation to investigate the facts and to identify, prosecute and punish, as appropriate, those responsible ................ 198 C.1) Investigation, identification, trial and punishment, as appropriate, of all those responsible ................................ 199 C.2) Determinación of the whereabouts of the disappeared victims ...................................................................... 201 D. Measures of rehabilitation and satisfaction ............................................................................................................ 201 D.1) Rehabilitation ........................................................................................................................................ 202 D.2) Satisfaction........................................................................................................................................... 204 D.2.a) Publication and dissemination of the Judgment ................................................................................... 204 D.2.b) Public act to acknowledge international responsibility ........................................................................... 205 D.2.c) Preparation of an audiovisual documentary ....................................................................................... 205 D.3) Other measures requested ...................................................................................................................... 206 E. Compensation .................................................................................................................................................... 207 E.1) General arguments of the parties and of the Commission ............................................................................. 207 E.2) Specific arguments concerning pecuniary damage ....................................................................................... 208 E.3) Specific arguments concerning non-pecuniary damage ................................................................................ 208 E.4) Considerations of the Court ..................................................................................................................... 209 E.4.1) Pecuniary damage ......................................................................................................................... 209 E.4.2) Non-pecuniary damage .................................................................................................................. 213 F. Costs and expenses ............................................................................................................................................ 214 4

Seleccionar párrafo de destino3