sufficient information to determine whether they suffered physical or mental effects as
people living with HIV.194
164. Consequently, the State is responsible for the violation of the obligation to ensure
the right to personal integrity recognized in Article 5(1) of the American Convention to the
detriment of: Ismar Ramírez Chajón, José Cupertino Ramírez, Sebastián Emilio Dueñas,
Julia Aguilar, Luis Rubén Isabel Alvarez Flores, Saira Elisa Barrios, Felix de Jesús Cabrera
Morales, César Noé Cancinos Gómez, Aracely Cinto, Luis Rolando Cuscul Pivaral, María
Felipe Pérez, Mardo Luis Hernández and Hernández, Luis Armando Linares Ruano, Pascuala
de Jesús Mérida Rodríguez, Darinel López Montes de Oca, Audencio Rodas Rodríguez, Zoila
Marina Pérez Ruíz, Santiago Francisco Valdéz Aguilar, Karen Judith Samayoa Vásquez,
Francisco Sop Quiej, Miguel Lucas Vaíl, Sandra Lisbeth Zepeda Herrera, Petrona López
Robledo, Rita Mariana Dubón Orozco, María Blanca Vaíl López, José Rubén Delgado López,
Elsa Miriam Estrada Ruíz, Guadalupe Herminia Cayaxon García, Juana Aguilar, Melvin Yovani
Ajtun Escobar, Felipe Tebalan Ordoñez, Martina Candelaria Alvarez Estrada, Ismerai Olibia
García Castañon, Santos Isacar Vásquez Barrios, Marta Alicia Maldonado Paz, Dora Marina
Martínez Sofoifa, Israel Perez Charal, Teresa Magdalena Ramírez Castro, Jorge Armando
Tavares Barreno, Santos Vásquez Oliveros, Iris Carolina Vicente Baullas, Facundo Gómez
Reyes, Reina López Mujica, Alberto Quiché Cuxeva, Silvia Mirtala Alvarez Villatoro and
Corina Dianeth Robledo Alvarado.
Teresa Magdalena Ramírez Castro, xxxix) Jorge Armando Tavares Barreno, xl) Santos Vásquez Oliveros xli) Iris
Carolina Vicente Baullas, xlii) Facundo Gómez Reyes, xliii) Reina López Mujica, xliv) Alberto Quiché Cuxeva, xlv)
Silvia Mirtala Álvarez Villatoro and xlvi) Corina Dianeth Robledo Alvarado.
With regard to i) Luis Edwin Cruz Gramajo, ii) Ingrid Janeth Barillas Martínez, iii) Olga Marina Castillo, the
Court notes that it has insufficient information to determine their situation.
194
57