V EVIDENCE A. Admissibility of the documentary evidence 33. The Court received various documents submitted as evidence by the Commission13 and by the State,14 which were admitted under Article 57 of the Rules of Procedure, because they were Annexes to the brief of submission of the case: Annex 1. Private accusation by Sixto Núñez Naranjo against the fourth criminal judge on May 8, 2002 (case file of evidence, pages 4 to 9); Annex 2. Official Letter No. 2070-PJT-CP9-2001 from the Chief of the Judicial Police of Tungurahua to the Prosecutor of Tungurahua (case file of evidence, pages 11 to 18); Annex 3. Police Report No. 1123-PJT-CP9-2001 of August 16, 2001 (case file of evidence, pages 20 to 26); Annex 4. Corresponds to the same document as Annex 3; Annex 5. Police Report No. 1376-CP9-2001 of October 18, 2001 (case file of evidence, pages 29 to 31); Annex 6. Version translated by Sixto Núñez on April 29, 2002 before the Prosecutor of Tungurahua (case file of evidence, pages 33 and 34); Annex 7. Statement of MV rendered on August 15, 2001 (case file of evidence, pages 36 and 37); Annex 8. Corresponds to the same document as Annex 5; Annex 9. Official letter from the Central Board of Peasants No. 88-CJDCQ-2002 addressed to the Chief Prosecutor of Tungurahua on June 30, 2002 (case file of evidence, pages 39 and 40); Annex 10. Provisional stay of proceedings order from the Fourth Criminal Court of Tungurahua dated December 11, 2002 (case file of evidence, pages 42 to 49); Annex 11. Recognition of the facilities of the National Police of Quero carried out by the Fiscal Delegation of the Tungurahua District on April 26, 2002 (case file of evidence, pages 51 and 52); Annex 12. Corresponds to the same document as Annex 1; Annex 13. Resolution of the Fourth Criminal Court of Tungurahua on May 10, 2002 (case file of evidence, pages 54 to 57); Annex 14. Habeas corpus petition filed before the Tungurahua Superior Court of Justice on July 11, 2002 (case file of evidence, pages 59 to 68); Annex 15. Report from the Fourth Substitute Criminal Judge of Tungurahua to the Tungurahua Superior Court of Justice on July 17, 2002 (case file of evidence, pages 70 to 73); Annex 16. Resolution of the Second Chamber of the Superior Court of Justice of Tungurahua on July 31, 2002 (case file of evidence, pages 75 to 81); Annex 17. Preliminary hearing minutes of the Fourth Criminal Court of Tungurahua Substitute of December 11, 2002 (case file of evidence, pages 83 and 84); Annex 18. Corresponds to the same document as Annex 10; Annex 19. Official Letter No. 3585-CP9-2004 from the Chief of the Judicial Police of Tungurahua dated October 15, 2004 (case file of evidence, page 86) and Copy of the case file before the Commission (case file of evidence, pages 87 to 1448). 14 Annexes to the answering brief: Annex 1. Police Report No. 1123-PJT-CP9-2001 of August 16, 2001 (case file of evidence, pages 1452 to 1458); Annex 2. Resolution initiating the public prosecutor's investigation of Ecuador dated May 8, 2002 (case file of evidence, pages 1460 to 1463); Annex 3. Request for a Summons to Trial filed by the prosecutor on September 23, 2002 (case file of evidence, pages 1465 to 1470); Annex 4. Preliminary hearing minutes of the Fourth Criminal Court of Tungurahua on December 10 and 11, 2001 (case file of evidence, pages 1472 to 1503); Annex 5. Memorandum No. FPT-FCQ-2020-00078-M from the Prosecutor General's Office of December 18, 2020 (case file of evidence, pages 1512 and 1513); Annex 6. Memorandum No. FPT-FCQ-2021-00024-M from the Prosecutor General's Office of March 18, 2021 (case file of evidence, pages 1515 to 1517); Annex 7. Official Letter No. FGE-CGAJP-DDHPC-2021007878-O from the Prosecutor General's Office of December 16, 2021 (case file of evidence, pages 1519 to 1521); Annex 8. Brief presented by Sixto Núñez before the Fourth Criminal Judge on August 13, 2002 (case file of evidence, folio 1523); Annex 9. Official Letter No. 406-MFDT-BP-02 from the Prosecutor of Tungurahua on August 13, 2002 (case file of evidence, page 1525); Annex 10. Police report from July 15, 2001 at 4:00 PM (case file of evidence, page 1527); Annex 11. Police report from July 15, 2001 at 5:30 PM (case file of evidence, page 1529); Annex 12. Corresponds to the same document as Annex 1; Annex 13. Protocol for the action, search, and investigation of missing persons issued by Resolution of the Judiciary Council 160 recorded in the Official Gazette 875 of January 21, 2013 (case file of evidence, pages 1539 to 1546); Annex 14. Compliance report before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights on the Case of Fredy Marcelo Núñez Naranjo et al., Case No. 12,744, from the Human Rights Registrar of September 2019 (case file of evidence, pages 1549 to 1551); Annex 15. Memorandum No. FPT-FCQ-2020-00057-M from the Prosecutor General's Office of October 26, 2020 (case file of evidence, pages 1553 and 1554); Annex 16. Memorandum No. FPT-FCQ-2020-00078-M from the Prosecutor General's Office of December 18, 2020 (case file of evidence, pages 1556 and 1557); Annex 17. Memorandum No. FPTFCQ-2021-00024-M from the Prosecutor General's Office of March 18, 2021 (case file of evidence, pages 1559 to 1561); Annex 18. Compliance report before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights on the Case of Fredy Marcelo Núñez Naranjo et al., Case No. 12,744, from the Human Rights Registrar of October 2020 (case file of evidence, pages 1563 to 1572); Annex 19. Compliance report before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights on the Case of Fredy Marcelo Núñez Naranjo et al., Case No. 12,744, from the Human Rights Registrar of June 2021 (case file of evidence, pages 1574 to 1583); Annex 20. Compliance report before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights in the Case of Fredy Marcelo Núñez Naranjo et al., Case No. 12,744 of December 2020 (case file of evidence, pages 1585 to 1604), and Annex 21. Compliance report on the Case of Fredy Marcelo Núñez Naranjo et al., Case No. 12,744, from the Ministry of Administration of December 2020 (case file of evidence, folios 1607 to 1613). 13 -11-