5 13. It spring from the foregoing our difference with some of the colleagues, members of the Court, only and exclusively as to the hearing of facts committed outside the temporal scope that comprises the recognition of competence on the part of the State. This does not mean, of course, the exclusion from the judgment of the description of the incidents related to situations that ended in a violation, which is the Court's duty to hear. Judge Diego García-Sayán Judge Pablo Saavedra Alessandri Secretary Judge Sergio García Ramírez Judge