not be complete, because it is not easy to presume that the illegal act expressly
acknowledges that its purpose is other than the one indicated in the norm.”163
122.
Furthermore, regarding the origin of the expression, it has been indicated that:
“VI. Origin of the expression
The expression détournement de pouvoir (abuse of power) was first used by León Aucoc to refer to
the policing powers of an administrative agent, who used these powers for reasons other than those
established by positive law.
Subsequently, Laferrière systematized and developed the expression to the level at which we know it
today. Thus, he defined détournement de pouvoir as the irregularity consisting in diverting a legal
power from the purpose for which it was established and using it for purposes for which it was not
designed.”
[…]
“Abuse of power is an offense committed by a public official or agent by issuing an administrative
decision with a subjective motive that impairs the purpose of general interest that the legislator had
in mind when granting the power. […] In the abuse of power, the administrative decision has a
purpose that is contrary to the general interest, because the agent who issues the decision is guided
by subjective or internal motives. While in the case of unreasonableness and arbitrariness, the official
may act in pursuit of the purpose of the law, but the means he uses are disproportionate.”164
123.
Similarly, it has been maintained that:
“Theoretically, the principle of the abuse of power is applicable in three cases, in all of which the
officials acts with a different objective to the one sought by the law he or she executes:
a) The official acts with a personal objective: under this hypothesis, his actions are guided by
revenge, partisanship, profit, etc. In these cases, even though the act responds objectively to the
conditions expressly required by the law, it is illegal because it contravenes the purpose of the law;
b) The official acts in order to benefit one or several third parties: this happens, also without
objectively violating the law, when the official uses administrative powers in order to benefit third
parties; for example, if an official is authorized to enter into direct contracts without public
competitions and he contracts a certain company because it belongs to his friends and he wants to
help them win the contract, etc.
c) The official acts in order to benefit the administration: this is a fairly common case, and probably
the one in which there is most abuse of power. The official, imbued with an erroneous statist and
fiscalist spirit, as the Argentine official usually is owing to the pressure of misguided doctrinaires,
seeks to exercise the power of the law to the undue benefit of the administration or of the State.
Thus, he tries to collect the most fines, not to discourage non-compliance with municipal ordinances,
but to obtain funds for the municipality; he uses the powers granted to him by the state of emergency
(internal security) for ordinary purposes of controlling morality, etc.”165
124. For their part, authors such as Atienza and Ruiz Manero explain abuse of power as
“… a species within the genus of “exces de pouvoir,” inasmuch as it is a category created to
subject discretional administrative acts to judicial control.”166 According to these authors,
163
Ibidem, p. 395.
164
Barraza, Javier Indalecio, “La finalidad del acto administrativo y la desviación de poder”, Revista Ius
Publicum, Universidad Santo Tomás, v. 14, No. 29, 2012, pp. 51-52.
165
Gordillo, Agustín, Tratado de derecho administrativo y obras selectas, tome 5, primeras obras, 1st
edition, Buenos Aires, FDA, 2012, p. EAA-IV-18; ibíd., El acto administrativo, 1ª edición, Buenos Aires, AbeledoPerrot, 1963, reprinted as Libro II of the Tratado de derecho administrativo y obras selectas, cit., available at:
http://www.gordillo.com/tome5.html and http://www.gordillo.com/pdf_tome5/02/02-capitulo4.pdf
166
Atienza, Manuel and Ruiz Manero, Juan, “Ilícitos atípicos”, Editorial Trotta, Madrid, 2000, chapter IV,
section 27, p. 92.
35
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos