special care for vulnerable and marginalized groups, and this must be provided progressively in
accordance with available resources and the applicable domestic laws.325
235. As it has reiterated in its recent case law, the Court considers that the nature and scope of
the obligations derived from the protection of the right to health include aspects that are
enforceable immediately, and also aspects that have a progressive character.326 In this regard,
the Court recalls that, in relation to the former (obligations that are enforceable immediately),
States must adopt effective measures to guarantee access, without discrimination, to the services
recognized as part of the right to health; guarantee the equality of rights between women and
men and, in general, advance towards the full effectiveness of the economic, social, cultural and
environmental rights (ESCER). Regarding the latter (obligations of a progressive character), the
progressive implementation signifies that States Parties have the specific and constant obligation
to advance as rapidly and efficiently as possible towards the full effectiveness of this right, to the
extent of available resources, and by legislation or other appropriate means. In addition, States
are obliged to ensure non-retrogressivity in relation to the rights that have been achieved. Based
on the foregoing, the obligations to respect and to ensure rights, together with the adoption of
measures of domestic law (Articles 1(1) and 2 of the Convention), are fundamental to achieve
their effectiveness. 327
236. This Court finds that representative Jemio Mendoza’s arguments have been substantiated
regarding the violation of Patricia Gallardo’s right to health, which was exacerbated during her
house arrest because the State ceased to provide her with her treatment. The Court has noted
(supra para. 189) that Ms. Gallardo Ardúz was a victim of acts of torture and that those acts
caused her physical and mental aftereffects that violated her right to health. In addition, according
to the ITEI medical report of July 14, 2021, “Patricia Gallardo suffers from irreversible ailments
that require permanent treatment; she needs special food, medication and, above all, daily
physiotherapy to supplement the treatment with medication.”328 On several occasions, Ms.
Gallardo Ardúz submitted her claims regarding health care to address the effects of the torture
and ill-treatment she experienced,329 and the State has not responded to them. Therefore, the
Court finds that the State violated the right to health of Patricia Gallardo Ardúz.
237. This Court also finds that the proven facts reveal that several actions taken by the State in
relation to the events of this case entailed a violation of the alleged victims’ right to health.
Consequently, in application of the iura novit curia principle, which international case law has
repeatedly validated, and under which the judge has the authority – and even the duty – to apply
the legal provisions relevant to a case even when the parties have not expressly invoked them,330
the Court finds it necessary to examine the facts in light of the right to health of the other alleged
victims in this case.
325
Cf. Case of Cuscul Pivaral et al. v. Guatemala. Preliminary objection, merits, reparations and costs. Judgment
of August 23, 2018. Series C No. 359, para. 39, and Case of Manuela et al. v. El Salvador, supra, para. 185.
Cf. Case of Poblete Vilches et al. v. Chile, supra, para. 104, and Case of Manuela et al. v. El Salvador, supra,
para. 186.
326
327
Cf. Case of Muelle Flores v. Peru. Preliminary objections, merits, reparations and costs. Judgment of March 6,
2019. Series C No. 375, para. 190, and Case of Manuela et al. v. El Salvador, supra, para. 186.
328
Medical report prepared by Marcelo Flores of the ITEI on July 14,2021 (evidence file, folio 10401).
Cf. Brief submitted by Patricia Gallardo Ardúz to the Deputy Attorney for the State’s Legal Defense and
Representation of the Attorney General’s Office on September 21, 2020 (evidence file, folios 10264 to 10283).
329
330
Cf. Case of Velásquez Rodríguez v. Honduras. Merits, supra, para. 163, and Case of Guachalá Chimbo et al. v.
Ecuador, supra, para. 205.
66
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos