para. 81). During the press conference, government authorities presented the alleged victims as
those responsible for the robbery of the Prosegur truck, even though they had not been formally
indicted and prior to the hearing on precautionary measures.
257. The impact of the press conference in the media had a negative effect on the honor of the
alleged victims who were presented as guilty parties before they had been formally indicted in
any way. In addition, it had a special impact on the honor and reputation of Gabriel Valencia
Alarcón, Edwin Rodríguez Alarcón, Luis Fernando Lulleman Gutiérrez, Victoria Gutiérrez de
Lulleman, Jenny Paola Lulleman de Zaconeta, Julia Mamanu Mamani and Mauricio Valenzuela
Valencia who were presented as members of a criminal band and subsequently acquitted or not
even indicted. Accordingly, during the public hearing, Mauricio Valenzuela, referring to the
presentation to the media, stated that “people judge me when they point at me; they say that I
am a crook and everything.” Meanwhile, in his statement, Alexis Eduardo Valencia recounted that
“in school, owing to my last name, everyone realized that I was Blas Valencia’s son and rejected
me; the boys hit me; they told me that they had seen my father on the television, that he was
the police agent with the black eye.”346 This reveals the stigmatization to which they were
subjected because they had been presented during the press conference as guilty parties, and
this violated their right to honor and dignity.
258. In addition, to the victims listed (supra para. 256), the children, Alexis Valencia Alarcón and
Claudio Centeno Valencia, were also present during the press conference, as was Mauricio
Valenzuela Valencia, although it was only the latter who was presented to the press with his name
as a member of the band of assailants. However, in the case of children who are detained, the
State is obliged to exercise its function of guarantor, adopting all the measures of care required
by a child’s vulnerability. In this regard, Rule 8 of the United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for
the Administration of Juvenile Justice (Beijing Rules) on the protection of privacy establishes: 8.1.
The juvenile's right to privacy shall be respected at all stages in order to avoid harm being caused
to her or him by undue publicity or by the process of labelling. 8.2 In principle, no information
that may lead to the identification of a juvenile offender shall be published.” Considering the
specific vulnerability of children and the position of the State as their guarantor, their mere
presence during the press conference where their family members were presented as guilty
parties is sufficient to find that their privacy had been violated and that they had been identified
as offenders; therefore, their right to honor and dignity was also violated.
259. Based on the above, the Court finds that the State violated Articles 8(2) and 11 of the
American Convention, in relation to Article 1(1) of this instrument, to the detriment of Blas
Valencia Campos, Norma Alarcón de Valencia, Gabriel Valencia Alarcón, Claudia Valencia Alarcón,
Edwin Rodríguez Alarcón, Luis Fernando Lulleman Gutiérrez, Oswaldo Lulleman Antezana, Victoria
Gutiérrez de Lulleman, Jenny Paola Lulleman de Zaconeta, Víctor Boggiano, Elacio Peña Córdova,
Genaro Ahuacho, Alfredo Bazán y Rosas, Mercedes Valencia Chuquimia, Julia Mamanu Mamani,
F.E.P.M., Eladio Cruz Añez, Carlos Enrique Castro Ramírez, Patricia Gallardo and Freddy Cáceres
Castro. In addition, the fact that it presented a juvenile before the press as a member of a criminal
band and allowed two children related to the alleged suspects to remain in the same space,
signified that the State violated Article 8(2) of the Convention, in relation to Articles 11, 19 and
1(1) of this instrument, to the detriment of Mauricio Valenzuela Valencia, Alexis Valencia Alarcón
and Claudio Centeno Valencia.
B.2. Alleged violation of the right of defense
260. The right of defense is a key component of due process and obliges the State, at all times,
to treat the individual as a true subject of the proceedings, in the broadest sense of the concept,
346
Affidavit made by Alexis Eduardo Valencia Alarcón on June 14, 2022 (evidence file, folio 12621).
72
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos