though some investigative procedures were conducted, on April 8, 2014, the prosecutor in charge
of the investigation presented a rejection resolution, considering that there were insufficient
indications and evidence to prove what had happened. In response to this request, the Vice
Minister of Justice and Human Rights filed an objection on October 23, 2014, which was not
decided until September 12, 2019, when an order was issued to continue the investigation. Since
then, procedures have been conducted and requests for information issued and, as a result, two
individuals have been formally indicted and another one charged for the crimes of ill-treatment
and torture.
272. This Court has held that a prolonged delay in the proceedings may constitute, in itself, a
violation of judicial guarantees.359 The assessment of the reasonable time should be analyzed in
each specific case based on the total duration of the proceedings from the first procedural act until
the final judgment is handed down, including any appeals that may eventually be filed.360 In this
case, nine year passed before Bolivia opened, ex officio, the investigation into the alleged acts of
torture. Once initiated, the State’s failure to expedite it can be noted and this resulted in the
investigation being interrupted for more than five years. Moreover, it was reactivated as a result
of the notification of the Commission’s Admissibility Report in this case. This reveals a lack of
diligence by the State in complying with its obligation to investigate.
273. The State justified the delays in the investigation by the alleged victims lack of cooperation.
However, the Court notes that the participation of the alleged victims is not necessary for the
State’s obligation to investigate to arise. Indeed, it is the State’s duty to initiate, ex officio, such
investigations. In addition, when cases of sexual torture are involved, the investigation must try,
insofar as possible, to avoid revictimization or the reliving of the traumatic experience each time
the victim recalls or testifies about what happened.361 Therefore, it is not reasonable to require a
victim to describe the sexual abuse in each of her statements or each time that she addresses the
authorities. An examination of the file of this investigation does not reveal that special measures
were taken to assist and protect the alleged victims of sexual violence to avoid their
revictimization.
274. Therefore, owing to the lack of diligence in the investigation of the acts of torture suffered
by the alleged victims, the Court finds that the State failed to respect the obligation to investigate
the acts of torture which is derived from Article 5 of the Convention in relation to Article 1(1) of
this instrument, as well as Articles 1, 6 and 8 of the Inter-American Convention to Prevent and
Punish Torture and, as applicable, Article 7(b) of the Convention of Belém do Pará, to the
detriment of Genaro Ahuacho Luna; Norma Lupe Alarcón de Valencia; Alfredo Bazán y Rosas;
Víctor Manuel Boggiano Bruzzón; Freddy Cáceres Castro; Carlos Enrique Castro Ramírez; Claudio
Tito Centeno Valencia; Carlos Eladio Cruz Añez; Patricia Catalina Gallardo Ardúz; Victoria Gutiérrez
Aguilar de Lulleman; Oswaldo Lulleman Antezana; Jenny Paola Lulleman Gutiérrez de Zaconeta;
Luis Fernando Lulleman Gutiérrez; Raúl Oswaldo Lulleman Gutiérrez; Julia Mamanu Mamani;
Elacio Peña Córdova; María Fernanda Peña Gallardo; F.E.P.M.; Edwin Rodríguez Alarcón; Álvaro
Taboada Valencia; Alexis Valencia Alarcón; Claudia Valencia Alarcón; Gabriel Valencia Alarcón;
Blas Valencia Campos; Mercedes Valencia Chuquimia, and Mauricio Valenzuela Valencia.
inhuman acts against the 26 alleged victims in this case; thus, the Court rejects the representative’s allegation that
the investigation did not take María Fernanda Peña Gallardo into account.
Cf. Case of Hilaire, Constantine and Benjamin et al. v. Trinidad and Tobago, Merits, reparations and costs.
Judgment of June 21, 2002. Series C No. 94, para. 145, and Case of Sales Pimenta v. Brazil. Preliminary objections,
merits, reparations and costs. Judgment of June 30, 2022. Series C No. 454, para. 106.
359
360
107.
Cf. Case of Suárez Rosero v. Ecuador. Merits, supra, para. 71, and Case of Sales Pimenta v. Brazil, supra, para.
361
Cf. Case of Fernández Ortega et al. v. Mexico, supra, para. 196, and Case of Bedoya Lima et al. v. Colombia,
supra, para. 139.
76
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos