16
existed between Kenneth Ney Anzualdo Castro and Martin Javier Roca Casas,
mentioned by the State, since the Tribunal cannot assume that, in view of that
relationship and that they were friends or fellow students, the former was an
informant of the security forces or that he was disappeared by Sendero Luminoso.
43.
Apart from the foregoing, the Court considers that the version of the facts
presented by the State during this proceeding is inconsistent with what the State’s
judicial organs sustained in the processing of the request for extradition of former
President Fujimori. It seems appropriate to note that the Ad Hoc State’s Attorney
Office, in the cases of Fujimori- Montesinos, considered that, according to the
Logbook 1 of the basement of the SIE, a person identified as "detainee 5C”- that
corresponded to Kenneth Ney Anzualdo Castro- was admitted to the basement in the
night of December 16, 1993, at 10:10 P.M.; and that it would be possible to
establish, from the analysis of the Logbooks 1 and 2 of the basements of SIE, that
detainee 5C would have been held in said basements from December 16, 1993 to
December 30, 1993 and that he would have been daily visited by an Army officer.
After December 30, 1993, detainee 5C does not appear any longer in the entries of
Logbooks 1 and 2 of the basements of the SIE and there is no specification as to the
exit reason or final destination. According to the abovementioned Ad Hoc State’s
Attorney Office, considering the non-return exit of Anzualdo Castro from the entries
of the SIE, it is presumed that he was eliminated and his body later cremated in the
incinerators installed in the basements of SIE.46
44.
In the report forwarded to the State’s Attorney of the Supreme Court of Chile,
in relation to said request for extradition, it is indicated that the information above
mentioned allows concluding that there are manifold, serious, and consistent
indications, from which it is possible to conclude for certain that Kenneth Anzualdo
Castro was detained by agents of the State.47 Said amendment to the request of the
State’s Attorney, as well as its admission by the Supreme Court, considers as a fact
that the forced disappearance is attributable to state agents, including to highranking authorities at that time. The Court considers that, even though the
statements made by the State were expressed in different procedures and places, on
the one hand, in the extradition proceeding of former President Fujimori and on the
other hand, in the proceeding before this Tribunal, there is a contradiction that
disqualifies the position expressed by the State.
45.
Lastly, the State indicated during the hearing that the hypothesis of the
disappearance of Mr. Anzualdo Castro by Sendero Luminoso "is not under
investigation in the criminal proceeding that is currently conducted.” This would
prove, contrary to what the State seeks, that the own statements of the State
regarding such connection are not based on findings made at the domestic level by
judicial or investigation authorities, courts or investigative authorities, which
invalidates the State’s position.
46.
It is also relevant that Mr. Anzualdo was made disappeared two days before he
was due to go to the State's Attorney Office to render a statement about the
circumstances of the disappearance of Martin Roca Casas. This is why, a few days
46
Cf. amendment to request the Active Extradition of the Ad Hoc State’s Attorney Office of March
21, 2006 (record of evidence, Volume VIII, appendix 16 to the Brief of Pleadings and Motions, page
2920). See also, affidavit rendered by Victor Manuel Quinteros Marquina on March 16, 2009 (records of
evidence, volume XI, pages 4350-4362).
47
Cf. Report of the State's Attorney Office of the Supreme Court of Chile in relation to the request
for extradition of the Peruvian citizen Alberto Fujimori, of June 7, 2007 (record of evidence, volume VIII,
appendix 17 to the Brief of Pleadings and Motions, page 2979).
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos