May 25, 2000, Ms. Bedoya was intercepted, kidnapped, and subjected to numerous physical, sexual,
and verbal assaults, all while she was engaging in her journalism work. Likewise, in the previous
section, the Court has found it proven that the attacks had a clear connection with her journalism
activity and were intended to punish, intimidate, and silence her (supra para. 103).
109. Regarding the individual dimension of the right to freedom of thought and expression, the Court
recalls that this includes the right to use any appropriate means to disseminate opinions, ideas, and
information and make it reach the largest number of recipients. 252 In this case, the Court reiterates
that the attacks and violence to which Ms. Bedoya was subjected on May 25, 2000 were due to her
profession as a journalist. Likewise, the Office of the Public Prosecutor of the Nation itself indicated
on several occasions the connection of the attacks to her profession as a journalist. 253 The Court
therefore concludes that this attack was intended to single out this journalist for punishment and
intimidation and thus impact the individual dimension of her right to freedom of expression.
110. Not only did the attacks on Ms. Bedoya and the violations of her freedom of expression have
an individual impact on her, they also had a collective impact, both on Colombian society in terms of
people’s right to information and on her fellow journalists when it came to doing their own work. This
is where the second dimension of the right to freedom of expression comes into play—that is, the
social dimension, regarding which the Court has indicated that it also includes the right of everyone
to hear opinions, stories, and news from third parties. 254
111. The Court notes, firstly, that Ms. Bedoya covered matters of great public interest, such as the
alleged arms trafficking, the alleged purchase and sale of hostages, and other human rights violations
that were being committed in the La Modelo Prison. 255 In this regard, the Court has emphasized that
freedom of expression, particularly in matters of public interest, “is a cornerstone of the very
existence of a democratic society.” Without an effective guarantee of freedom of expression the
democratic system is weakened and there is a breakdown of pluralism and tolerance; the
mechanisms of control and complaint that citizens have may become inoperable and, indeed, a fertile
ground is created for authoritarian systems to take root. 256
112. Likewise, the Court’s case law has addressed this impact on the victims of violence and on other
journalists who could reasonably fear that this type of human rights violation will be repeated and,
as a consequence, self-censor their work. 257 But also, the Court observes that the consequences of
the social impact of this violation were differentiated due to the fact that the person attacked was a
female journalist. Thus, as indicated by Ms. Bedoya before this Court, following the events of May
25, 2000 there were:
Many cases hushed up, situations of fellow female journalists who had to face things similar
to what happened to me, but as the armed conflict mutated and changed, intimidation
against women journalists without question became more common, especially persecution
of them and discrediting their work for being women. 258
252
Cf. Case of Ivcher Bronstein v. Peru, supra, para. 147, Case of Carvajal Carvajal et al. v. Colombia, supra, para. 172.
253
Cf. Office of the Attorney General of the Nation, Resolution of June 6, 2000 (evidence file, folio 155).
254
Cf. Case of Ivcher Bronstein v. Peru, supra, para. 148, and Case of Carvajal Carvajal et al. v. Colombia, supra, para.
172.
255
Cf. Statement from Jineth Bedoya Lima given at the public hearing held on March 15, 22, and 23, 2021 within the
framework of the 140th regular sessions.
256
Cf. Advisory Opinion OC-5/85 para. 70, and Case of Carvajal Carvajal et al. v. Colombia, supra, para. 174.
257
Cf. Case of Vélez Restrepo and Family v. Colombia, supra, para. 212.
Cf. Statement from Jineth Bedoya Lima given at the public hearing held on March 15, 22, and 23, 2021 within the
framework of the 140th regular sessions.
258
43