9 judgments have not been fulfilled and that as a result of the excessive delay the health of the teachers has declined significantly and some have died.5 19. Based in the foregoing, the petitioners hold that the State has committed violations of Articles 8, 21, 25, and 26 of the American Convention, taken in conjunction with Articles 1(1) and 2 of the same international instrument. years); Castro González, Rómulo Edgardo (59 years); Espinoza Cortés, Adelina de las Mercedes (59 years); Fuentes Molina, Olivia del Carmen (59 years); Gómez Moraga, Héctor Antonio (59 years); Guajardo Parra, Elizabeth del Carmen (59 years); Hernándes Vásquez, Gloria Elizabeth (59 years); Peña Aravena, Manuel Antonio (59 years); Rodríguez Torres, María Cecilia (59 years); Pérez Espinoza, Edith Adriana (59 years); Alarcón Romero, Hugo Alberto (58 years); Espinoza Campos, Leonor Clarina (58 years); Guajardo Gutuerrez (sic), Juana Guillermina (58 years); Meza Gatica, Angélica Violeta (58 years); Muñoz Hidalgo, Patricio Alberto (58 years); Opazo Pérez, Carmen Cecilia (58 years); Díaz Campos, Abraham del Rosario (58 years); Yevenes Faúndez, Sonia del Tránsito (58 years); Aguilar Lazcano, Ana Elena (58 years); Morán González, Sergio Iván (57 years); Muñoz Durán, Rosa Elena (57 years); Pérez Retamal, Elsa del Pilar (57 years); Montesino Cancino, Blanca Josefina (56 years); Rodríguez Torres, Orfelina Angélica (56 years); Andia Cariqueo, José Gustavo (54 years); Landeros Novoa, Eduardo Antonio (54 years); Salazar Aguayo, Sonia Beatriz (54 years), Tapia Tapia, Stanly Antonio (54 years); Vera Fuentes, Yoconda de las Nieves (54 years); Peña Ríos, Vety de las Mercedes (54 years); Martínez Espinoza, Nilvia Irene (53 years). “ALEGRÍA CANCINO, LUCILA ET AL. v. Municpality of Pelluhue,” Case 218-93; and “ARAVENA ESPINOZA, MARÍA MERCEDES ET AL. v. Municpality of Pelluhue,” Case 222-93, of Chanco Magistrate’s Court for payment of entitlement under Article 40 of D.L. 3.551/1980. Espinoza Suazo, Fidelina del Carmen (*); Canales Paredes, Gladys Ester (80 years); Orellana Leal, Sofanor (71 years); Bravo Aravena, Adriana (70 years); Yáñez Gallardo, Pedro Ramón (69 years); Torres Yáñez, Eduardo Onofre (68 years); Cárdenas Márquez, Irma Ester (64 years); Salazar Soto, María Benita (63 years); Ayala González, Joaquín del Carmen (62 years); González Jaque, Adrián Gustavo (62 years); Domínguez Ávila, Isabel de las Mercedes (61 years); Mora de la Hoz, Elena del Carmen (61 years); Espinoza Vallejos, Juan de la Cruz (60 years); Zambrano González, Wilson Edgardo (60 years); Orellana Guajardo, María Ninfa (59 years); Vera Aravena, Mónica Beatriz (59 years); Araya Godoy, Melba Ivone (58 years); Jara Amigo, Juan Francisco (58 years); Maureira Cáceres, María Socorro (58 years); Paredes Orellana, Elena del Carmen (58 years); Valdés Medina, Manuel Eduardo (58 years); Muñoz Luna, Teolina Tavita (58 years); Alegría Cancino, Lucila de las Mercedes (57 years); Faúndez Opazo, Alicia de las Mercedes (57 years); Hernández Pérez, Crescencia Ester (57 years); Leiva Salas, José Heriberto (57 years), Aravena Espinoza, María Mercedes (57 years); Villaseñor Jara, Jaime Antonio (56 years); Guayiler Yáñez, Gloria María (55 years); Andaur Alarcón, María Marlene (54 years); Flores Acuña, Patricia (54 years); Fuentes Recabal, Miriam del Carmen (53 years). (*) The petitioners report that the alleged victim in the proceedings before the IACHR has died. 5 According to information supplied by the petitioners at the working meeting of October 26, 2011, to date, the following alleged victims have died: from the Municpality of Chañaral: Alexis, J. Tornejo Campos; from the Municpality of Vallenar: Norma E. Valderrama Martínez, Silvia Edith Meléndez Cortés, Rosa Elena González Zepeda, Elba del C. Silva González, Ana Maria Eugenia Zamora Rowe, César Hernán Rivera Barrera, Enrique G. Cavada Mauske, María Edilia Valenzuela Portilla, Gladys Ruth González Rojas, Noel Salomon Zuleta Aguilera, Nolvia Luisa Rojas Veliz, Norma Antonia Marin Escobar, Maranda Yolanda Paez Buigley, Edmundo Mazimo Quezada Araya, Carlos E. Sepúlveda Godoy, Héctor Miguel Morales Morales, Cecilia del C. Pacheco Pacheco, Mateo Segundo Pierotic Cortés, Eduardo Hernando Concha Jirón, Felisa del C. Monardez lillo, Gregorio Víctor Castillo Marin; from the Municpality of Parral: Adq del C. Salvo Candia, Miguel Ángel Ruiz Morales, Alicia del C. Bustamante Pincheira, Nilsa Fredes Salazar Aravena, Fortunato de las Rosas Sepúlveda Gutiérrez, Gladys Elena del Carmen Muñoz González, Luis Arturo Fuentes Arriagada, Sonia A. Czischke Oyharcabal, José del Carmen Aravena Fuentes, Nahor Rivas Ahumada; from the Municpality of Cauquenes: Ilia Ester Díaz Canales, Gastón Aravena Concha, Ana Haydee Moya Ramírez, Ester Sáncehz Sánches, María Rojas Ortiz, Humilde Muñoz Flores, Idia Rosa López Barra, Elia L. Gutiérrez Lara, Elcira de las M. Cerro Jara, Benita Martínez Suazo, María Graciela Cisternas Cisternas, Gladys Muñoz Henríquez, José H. Aravena Verdugo, Brigido Durán Gutiérrez, Silvio Canales Espinoza, María Apolina Lara Pereira, José Villegas Olivos, Teresita Quiroz Ravanal, Antonio Vidal Valladares, Miguel Segundo Canales López, Crisila Sánchez Sepúlveda, Clodomiro Cancino Pérez, Julio del T. Cofre Cofre, María Ríos Muñoz, Fanor Arnaldo Pérez Guerrero, Morelia Reyes Parra, Ramón E. Díaz Espinoza, Gerarda Valenzuela Henríquez, Gladys Alvear Miranda, Heriberto Antonio Martínez Salazar, José Flavio Median Aravena; from the Municpality of Chanco: Celso del Carmen, Contreras Fuentealba, Guillermo Ernesto Contreras Jara, maría Liliam Álvarez Jara, Eduardo Andrés Yáñez Recabal, Rolando Antonio Molina Oyarce, Humberto Angel Muñoz Minchel, Rafaela de las Mercedes Escalona Espinoza, Liberato Segundo Vistoso Sepúlveda, Raúl Antonio Aldana Alvear, Luis Teobaldo Pérez Paredes; and from the Municpality of Pelluhue: Fidelina del Carmen Espinosa Suazo.