6
Groups and Organs of Society to Promote and Protect Universally Recognized
Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms.
f)
The Inter-American Court should conclude that the State has not
complied with the provisional measures requested by the Court, which, in
light of the Convention, constitutes a grave situation, without precedent in
the inter-American system for the protection of human rights, because it
endangers the lives and safety of human rights defenders;
g)
“[O]ne of the officials the State […] had assigned [to protect Liliana
Ortega] is being prosecuted as a hired assassin in the alleged murder of an
opposition leader; and
h)
“[W]hen planning these measures of protection, the following should
also be taken in account: [providing] COFAVIC personnel with bullet-proof
vests for their personal protection[;] […] the assignment of [...] motorcycles
[…] to ensure rapid transport during the difficult moment that some members
of the COFAVIC team have experienced; […] the installation of a special metal
detector in the entry to COFAVIC and of a double security door at the
COFAVIC offices with the characteristics and requirements determined by the
COFAVIC Board of Directors; [the appointment of a national prosecutor from
the Office of the Attorney General, in consultation with the petitioners, and
the State [should be] requested to make a statement [...] in favor of respect
and protection for the work of human rights defenders in Venezuela […].”
17.
The oral arguments of the State presented in this same public hearing, which
are summarized as follows:
a)
One of the results of the excess of democracy, the desire for
prominence, and the longing to be included in the participatory democracy of
the Venezuelans has been the disproportionate proliferation of nongovernmental human rights organizations;
b)
“It is clear that Liliana Ortega and her organization, COFAVIC, have
been a concern of the Venezuelan State.” “Quite simply there has been
disorder and disruption with regard to the precautionary measures and
specifically the provisional measures or including them in the measures of
protection for the physical and personal safety of Liliana Ortega […].” “The
implementation […] of precautionary or provisional measures, [...] is not easy
[…] under the bureaucratic system in our countries and owing to our
idiosyncrasy […]”;
c)
“[I]t is not at all easy, for a precautionary measure or a provisional
measure of protection to be established.”
Moreover, the request for
provisional measures was unnecessary, because the precautionary measures
were being observed, with some difficulties;
d)
In a country with the financial crisis that Venezuela is enduring, no
cabinet minister or president of an autonomous institution has the protection
requested by Liliana Ortega for herself and for COFAVIC. Also, the fact that
COFAVIC has its offices in “a place where there are frequent meetings and
even confrontations between supporters of the Government and the
opposition” cannot be attributed to the State;
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents