8.The petitioners state that one of the main ways in which the right to life is violated in
Venezuela is by the practice, blamed on local police, of unlawful and arbitrary detentions,
followed by extrajudicial executions, and the use of excessive and indiscriminate force. They
state that these violent “executions” are usually inflicted on young men, many of whom are
under 18 years of age and belong to the lower social classes, by police officers with an
established modus operandi, and with widespread impunity.
9.They allege that within the framework of this phenomenon, which has been almost
systematic in Venezuela since 1988, Aragua is one of the states in which the greatest number
of these “executions” is carried out by the agencies of law and order, in particular the public
law and order police (Cuerpo Policial de Seguridad y Orden Público).
10.They state that the characteristic opus operandi is as follows: “a) the event is described by
the police as a confrontation which in most cases involves altering the scene of the events, the
victim is taken by the police officers who attacked him, and left - usually lifeless – at a state
hospital, with no explanation given; b) uniforms and/or weapons and official equipment
(including vehicles) are used; c) the victim is discredited or criminalized with claims made that
he resisted arrest or had a criminal and/or police record; d) witnesses and family members are
intimidated, threatened, and even murdered.” They allege furthermore that most of these
events remain unpunished.
11.As background to the events, the petitioners indicate that the Landaeta Mejías family had
been the object of harassment, intimidation, and threats from members of the public law and
order police of the State of Aragua. They describe in particular a raid on their house, which
took place without a search warrant, and the death threat received by the alleged victim and
his brother Igmar Alexander Landaeta Mejías.
12.They state that the mother of the alleged victim went to the technical office of the judicial
police (Cuerpo Técnico de Policía Judicial) to make an official complaint concerning these
events and was told that the complaint could not be registered because “no action can be
taken against police officers.” They state that on November 17, 1996, officers of the Aragua
State law and order police murdered Igmar Alexander, brother of Eduardo José Landaeta
Mejías.
13.Regarding the events giving rise to the present petition, they state that on December 29,
1996, at approximately 9.0 a.m., Eduardo José Landaeta, who at that time was 17 years old,
was arrested in the street in the state capital of Maracay by a group of state police officers.
They state that the alleged victim was taken to a police station in the same city where the
police officers failed to inform his parents that the juvenile had been arrested.
14.According to the petitioners, at approximately 4.30 p.m., Eduardo José Landaeta managed
to telephone his father, Ignacio Landaeta Muñoz and inform him of his arrest, and asked his
father to bring the 30,000 Bolivars being demanded for his release. They state that when Mr.
Ignacio Landaeta appeared at the police station he was told that his son could not be released
because the State Police Central Command had been informed of his arrest.
15.The petitioners state that Mr. Ignacio Landaeta Muñoz asked a female officer in the police
station, as well as the sergeant on duty, to take care of his son given that he was under 18
and had recently been in receipt of threats. They state that at approximately 7.30 that night,
the alleged victim’s mother went to the police station and while she was waiting to be told the
reasons for the arrest of her son, two police officers in a white, Toyota Corolla vehicle, with no
number plates, arrived, asking for “Eduardo Landaeta”. According to the petitioners, these
officers were surprised to see the mother of Eduardo José Landaeta and they left. She
identified them as Gerardo Alcides Castillo Freites and Francisco Alberto Castillo Matute.
16.During the morning of December 30, 1996, they say that Eduardo José Landaeta was
transferred to the Central Command of the Aragua State Police, while his parents were
following proceedings and spending the night in front of the Command awaiting the transfer
2