20 Carmen Rosa Páez-Warton; birth certificate of Ms. Mónica Inés Castillo-Páez; testimony given before the Court by Mr. Cronwell Pierre Castillo-Castillo during in the merits stage of the proceedings; statements signed in the presence of a notary in the Netherlands, May 25, 1998, by Cronwell Pierre Castillo-Castillo, Mónica Inés Castillo-Páez and Carmen Rosa Páez-Warton; the Castillo Páez Case, Judgment of November 3, 1997); c) He was a sociology student at the Pontificia Universidad Católica del Peru, between the first semester of 1985 and the first semester of 1990 (Cf. letter from the rector of the Pontificia Universidad Católica del Peru, Mr. Hugo Saravia Swett, to the Minister of the Interior, dated November 6, 1990; copy of transcript No. 0002691 listing the courses passed by Ernesto Rafael Castillo-Páez, issued on February 23, 1998 by the Pontificia Universidad Católica del Peru; a copy of the cancelled payment voucher for the first semester of 1990 at the Pontificia Universidad Católica del Peru; a copy of an uncancelled payment voucher for the second semester of 1990 at the Pontificia Universidad Católica del Peru; press clippings titled: "En la Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos está el case Castillo-Páez" and "Policías asesinaron a estudiante" (Police killed student); and d) At the time of his detention, he was a mathematics teacher at the "Juan XXIII" Institute of Theological Studies, teaching twelve hours of classes per month, and drew a monthly salary of 13,200.000 intis, which at that time was the equivalent of approximately US$30.00 (thirty United States dollars). (Cf. teaching contract of Ernesto Rafael Castillo-Páez with the "Juan XXIII" Institute of Theological Studies, signed on September 6, 1988, and salary pay slip of Ernesto Rafael Castillo-Páez for October 1990); B) Concerning the victim’s next of kin: a) The victim’s known next of kin are Cronwell Pierre Castillo-Castillo, father, Carmen Rosa Páez-Warton, mother, and Mónica Inés Castillo-Páez, sister (cf. birth certificate and voter registration booklet of Ernesto Rafael Castillo-Páez; marriage certificate of Cronwell Pierre Castillo-Castillo and Carmen Rosa Páez-Warton; birth certificate of Ms. Mónica Inés Castillo-Páez); b) Said next of kin suffered material and moral damages as a consequence of the disappearance of Ernesto Rafael Castillo-Páez (cf. sworn income tax declaration of Mr. Cronwell Pierre CastilloCastillo for 1991; a copy of a "category four income tax withholding statement" for Mr. Cronwell Pierre Castillo-Castillo; a copy of the cover and preface of the book "Cálculo Diferencial" [Differential Calculus] by Michel Helfgott and Tomás Núñez, which contains an acknowledgment of the typing services of Ms. Carmen Rosa Páez-Warton; a copy of the sales contract for the Castillo-Páez family home, July 18, 1997; a copy of the certificate issued by Swedish attorney Eva Ericson, attorney ex oficio for Mónica Inés Castillo-Páez, which certifies the political asylum proceedings conducted in Sweden; a copy of the English-language report from the publication of "Human Rights Watch/Americas/Helsinki" for September 1996, volume 8, No. 14 (D), p. 29; a copy of the identification papers that grant political refuge to