3 (Denny Baptiste), 11,851 (Clarence Charles), 11,853 (Keiron Thomas), 11,855 (Anthony Garcia), 12,005 (Wilson Prince), 12,021 (Darrin Roger Thomas), 12,042 (Mervyn Edmund), 12,043 (Samuel Winchester), 12,052 (Martin Reid), 12,072 (Rodney Davis), 12,073 (Gangadeen Tahaloo), 12,075 (Noel Seepersad), 12,076 (Wayne Matthews), 12,082 (Alfred Frederick), 12,093 (Natasha De Leon), 12,111 (Vijay Mungroo), 12,112 (Phillip Chotalal), 12,129 (Naresh Boodram and Joey Ramiah), 12,137 (Nigel Mark), 12,140 (Wilberforce Bernard), 12,141 (Steve Mungroo), 12,148 (Peter Benjamin), 12,149 (Krishendath Seepersad), 12,151 (Allan Phillip), 12,152 (Narine Sooklal), 12,153 (Amir Mowlah), 12,156 (Mervyn Parris), and 12,157 (Francis Mansingh), received at its Secretariat between July 1997 and May 1999. 3) Below, the Court provides a chart, which summarizes the allegations made by the Commission in its Applications relating to the rights of the American Convention allegedly violated with respect to each of the alleged victims: Alleged Victim Haniff Hilaire Case No. 11,816 2 George Constantine 11,787 3 Wenceslaus James 11,814 4 Denny Baptiste 11,840 5 Clarence Charles 11,851 6 Keiron Thomas 11,853 7 Anthony Garcia 11,855 8 Wilson Prince 12,005 1 Violations alleged Mandatory Death Penalty (Arts. 1(1), 4(1), 5(1), 5(2), 5(6)) Delay (Arts. 1(1), 2, 7(5), 25) Mandatory Death Penalty (Arts. 1(1), 4(1), 5(1), 5(2), 8(1)) Prerogative of Mercy (Arts. 1(1), 4(6)) Delay and Fair Trial (Arts. 1(1), 2, 7(5), 8(1), 25) Unavailability of Legal Aid for Constitutional Motions (Arts. 1(1), 8, 25) Mandatory Death Penalty (Arts. 1(1), 4(1), 5(1), 5(2), 8(1)) Prerogative of Mercy (Arts. 1(1), 4(6)) Mandatory Death Penalty (Arts. 1(1), 4(1), 5(1), 5(2), 8(1)) Prerogative of Mercy (Arts. 1(1), 4(6)) Delay and Fair Trial (Arts. 1(1), 2, 7(5), 8(1), 25) Mandatory Death Penalty (Arts. 1(1), 4(1), 5(1), 5(2), 8(1)) Prerogative of Mercy (Arts. 1(1), 4(6)) Delay and Fair Trial (Arts. 1(1), 2, 7(5), 8(1), 25) Mandatory Death Penalty (Arts. 1(1), 4(1), 5(1), 5(2), 8(1)) Prerogative of Mercy (Arts. 1(1), 4(6)) Prison Conditions (Arts. 1(1), 5(1), 5(2)) Fair Trial (Arts. 1(1),8(2)(d), 8(2)(e)) Mandatory Death Penalty (Arts. 1(1), 4(1), 5(1), 5(2), 8(1)) Prerogative of Mercy (Arts. 1(1), 4(6)) Prison Conditions (Arts. 1(1), 5(1), 5(2)) Mandatory Death Penalty (Arts. 1(1), 4(1), 5(1), 5(2), 8(1)) Prerogative of Mercy (Arts. 1(1), 4(6)) Delay and Fair Trial (Arts. 1(1), 2, 7(5), 8(1), 25)