Judgment), allows this Court to conclude that the next of kin have been prevented from
knowing the truth through either judicial or extrajudicial channels.
301. The Court has considered that the next of kin of victims of gross violations of human
rights and society have the right to know the truth; hence, they must be informed of what
has happened.358 In addition, particularly in cases of forced disappearance, the Court has
established that the right to know the truth is part of the “right of the victims’ next of kin to
know their fate and, if applicable, the location of their remains.”359 The Court has indicated
that the denial of the truth about the whereabouts of a victim of forced disappearance
results in a form of cruel and inhuman treatment for the closest family members,360 and
therefore the violation of the right to personal integrity can be linked to a violation of their
right to know the truth.361
302. Based on the foregoing, the Court concludes that, by preventing the family members
from knowing the historical truth through the extrajudicial mechanism established by the
State itself in the Peace Accords and the National Reconciliation Act, added to the impunity
that persists in this case, the State violated the right to personal integrity recognized in
Article 5(1) and 5(2) of the American Convention, to the detriment of the next of kin of
Rudy Gustavo Figueroa Muñoz and of the disappeared victims.
C) Regarding the right to freedom of movement and residence
303. The Commission considered that the right to freedom of movement and residence
had been violated to the detriment of 12 victims,362 because “[i]n many cases [the
displacements] were the direct result of the forced disappearances and the other
manifestations of violence” and, in others, “they were the indirect result of the forced
disappearances, owing to the loss of the family’s financial support.” The representatives
agreed with the Commission and added another 14 people as victims of this alleged
violation.363 The State contested this alleged violation, because “at no time had it prohibited
the families from requesting asylum in another country owing to the persecution suffered”
and it considered that the arguments of the Commission and the representatives referred to
violations included in the rights established in Articles 5 and 17 of the American Convention,
the violations of which had been accepted by the State.
358
Cf. Case of Bámaca Velásquez v. Guatemala. Reparations and costs. Judgment of February 22, 2002.
Series C No. 91, para. 76 and 77, and Case of the Massacres of El Mozote and nearby places v. El Salvador, supra,
para. 298.
359
243.
Cf. Case of Velásquez Rodríguez. Merits, supra, para. 181, and Case of Gelman v. Uruguay, supra, para.
360
Cf. Case of Trujillo Oroza v. Bolivia. Merits. Judgment of January 26, 2000. Series C No. 64, para. 114,
and Case of González Medina and family members v. Dominican Republic, supra, para. 270.
361
Cf. Case of Anzualdo Castro v. Peru. Preliminary objection, merits, reparations and costs. Judgment of
September 22, 2009. Series C No. 202, para. 113.
362
The Commission indicated the following as victims: Makrina Gudiel Álvarez, María Agripina Álvarez,
Florentín Gudiel Ramos, José Francisco Gudiel Álvarez, Yolanda Gudiel Álvarez, Beatriz Gudiel Álvarez, Florentín
Gudiel Álvarez, María Consuelo Pérez Arenales, Sergio Raúl Villatoro Bran, Wendy Santizo Méndez, María Regina
Sánchez Morales and Fredy Anelson Gómez Moreira.
363
The representatives added as victims: Zonia Odilia Ortega Revolorio, Víctor Manuel Calderón Ortega,
Lourdes Melissa Calderón Ortega, Sandra Regina de la Candelaria Figueroa Carrillo, Sergio Alfonso Linares
Figueroa, Igor Santizo Méndez, Iris Carolina Sosa Pérez, Iván Orencio Sosa Pérez, Merlín Consuelo Sosa Pérez,
Linda Gardenia Sosa Pérez, María del Rosario Bran, Néstor Amílcar Villatoro Bran, Samuel Lisandro Villatoro Bran
and Norma Carolina Villatoro. The Court notes that, in their final written arguments, they added a further eight
individuals as victims of the alleged violation of Article 22. However, the Court notes that this request is timebarred.
- 103 -
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents