304. The Court has established that the right to freedom of movement and residence,
protected in Article 22(1) of the American Convention, is an essential condition for the free
development of the individual,364 and protects, inter alia, the right not to be forcibly
displaced within a State Party and not to have to leave forcibly the territory of the State in
which that individual lawfully resides.365 This right can be violated formally or by de facto
restrictions, if the State has not established the conditions and provided the means that
allow it to be exercised;366 for example, when a person is a victim of threats or harassment
and the State does not provide the necessary guarantees for that person to move and
reside freely within the territory in question.367 The Court has also indicated that the failure
to conduct an effective investigation of violent acts can foster or perpetuate exile or forced
displacement.368
305. Moreover, concurring with the international community, this Court reaffirms that the
obligation of the State of origin to guarantee the protection of the rights of displaced
persons entails not only the duty to take preventive measures but also to provide the
necessary conditions to facilitate a safe, decent and voluntary return to their usual place of
residence or voluntary resettlement in another part of the country. To this end, their full
participation in the planning and management of their return or reinsertion must be
guaranteed.369
306. The Court recalls the limitation to its temporal competence that exists in this case,
regarding which it has been established in previous cases that, when the forced
displacement occurs prior to the acceptance of the jurisdiction of the Court, the Court’s
competence to analyze a possible violation Article 22 is restricted to the analysis of the
existence of an impossibility of return.370 Consequently, the Court will examine the cases of
displacement that occurred after the acceptance of the Court’s jurisdiction on March 9,
1987, or that continued at that date and in which there is evidence of an impossibility of
return that can be attributed to the State (supra para. 30).
307. Regarding the displacement of the next of kin that took place after March 9, 1987,
the Court observes that the case file does not show a direct or immediate causal nexus
between these displacements and the forced disappearance of their family members or a
potential risk to their rights to life or to personal integrity that can be attributed to the
State. The Court observes that these displacements correspond to next of kin who testified
that they left Guatemala for other reasons.371
364
Cf. Case of Ricardo Canese v. Paraguay. Merits, reparations and costs. Judgment of August 31, 2004.
Series C No. 111, para. 115, and Case of the Massacres of El Mozote and nearby places v. El Salvador, supra, para.
186.
365
Cf. Case of the Mapiripán Massacre v. Colombia. Judgment of September 15, 2005. Series C No. 134,
para. 188, and Case of the Massacres of El Mozote and nearby places v. El Salvador, supra, para. 186.
366
Cf. Case of the Moiwana Community v. Suriname. Preliminary objections, merits, reparations and costs.
Judgment of June 15, 2005. Series C No. 124, paras. 119 and 120, and Case of the Río Negro Massacres v.
Guatemala, supra, para. 175.
367
Cf. Case of Valle Jaramillo et al. v. Colombia, supra, para. 139, and Case of the Río Negro Massacres v.
Guatemala, supra, para. 175.
368
Cf. Case of the Moiwana Community v. Suriname, supra, paras. 119 and 120, and Case of Vélez Restrepo
and family members v. Colombia, supra, para. 220.
369
Cf. Case of the Massacres of El Mozote and nearby places v. El Salvador, supra, para. 188.
370
Cf. Case of the Moiwana Community v. Suriname, supra, para. 43, and Case of the Río Negro Massacres v.
Guatemala, supra, para. 178.
371
The following were in this situation: María del Rosario Bran, María Regina Sánchez Morales, Fredy Anelson
Gómez Moreira, Víctor Manuel Calderón Ortega and Lourdes Melissa Calderón Ortega. Cf. affidavit made by María
del Rosario Bran de Villatoro on December 2, 2004 (file of annexes to the merits report, tome II, annex 47, folio
- 104 -
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents