membership in the guerrilla or, in extreme cases, the murder and the disappearance of their
members.”381 According to the CEH, the GAM was one of the organizations most affected.382
316. The Court emphasizes that, according to expert witness Doyle, the Diario Militar
provides evidence of the persecution of which the GAM members were victims; “based on
State intelligence, they became targets, as part of the internal enemies.”383 In this regard,
the Guatemalan Peace Secretariat has indicated that the third section of the Diario Militar
which contains the “Apoyo Mutual” document constitutes a list of the people “whose family
members belonged to the Grupo de Apoyo Mutual at that time.”384 Also, the fourth section
of the Diario Militar includes the GAM in a list entitled “List of ‘Front’ Organizations in the
service of the subversion.”385 In addition, in 1985 the Head of State at the time declared on
television that “the GAM was being manipulated by the subversion” and, therefore,
“measures would be taken to counter it and, henceforth, further protests would not be
tolerated.”386 In the Third Report on the Situation of Human Rights in Guatemala, the InterAmerican Commission underscored that “immediately after these declarations, the GAM
began to be severely harassed” and it was reported that, in the following months, two GAM
leaders were murdered and also the family members of one of them.387 All these facts
constitute relevant background information in relation to the situation of the GAM in 1984
and 1985.
317. However, the Court emphasizes that, according to the CEH, between 1989 and 1993,
the situation of danger and harassment against GAM members continued. In particular, the
report of the CEH recounted that, over this period, three GAM activists were kidnapped or
disappeared, and five more kidnapped and murdered. Also, in 1989, among other attacks, a
bomb exploded in front of the GAM offices and, on October 27 and 29, 1993, the offices
were raided.388 Consequently, it is clear that the situation of danger and harassment to
which the GAM members were subjected continued after the recognition of the Court’s
jurisdiction until at least 1993. The intimidating or threatening effect that this context could
have on the next of kin of the disappeared who were members of the GAM is clear to the
Court, and represented a de facto restriction of the right to freedom of association. In
381
CEH, supra, volume IV, pp. 229, para. 4511.
382
Cf. CEH, supra, volume IV, pp. 229 and 236, paras. 4512 and 4528.
383
Expert opinion provided by Katharine Temple Doyle before the Inter-American Court at the public hearing
in this case.
384
The list includes 10 persons, of whom six are victims in this case: Manuel Ismael Salanic Chiguil, Alfonso
Alvarado Palencia, Sergio Leonel Alvarado Arévalo, Otto René Estrada Illescas, Rubén Amílcar Farfán and Carlos
Guillermo Ramírez Gálvez. Cf. Diario Militar (file of annexes to the merits report, tome I, annex 11, folio 339);
Peace Secretariat, supra, p. 39. The Court notes that, according to the testimony of Sergio Leonel Alvarado
Arévalo’s siblings, their mother was a member of the GAM. However, she was not included as a presumed victim in
this case; hence this Court is unable to rule in this regard. Cf. Affidavit made by Luis Rodolfo Alvarado Arévalo on
April 18, 2005 (file of annexes to the merits report, tome II, annex 123, folio 1057) and affidavit of Tania Marbella
Alvarado Arévalo and Miguel Ángel Alvarado Arévalo of November 2, 2004 (file of annexes to the merits report,
tome II, annex 124, folio 1060).
385
Diario Militar (file of annexes to the merits report, tome I, annex 11, folio 346).
386
IACHR, Third Report on the Situation of Human Rights in the Republic of Guatemala, OEA/Ser.L/V/II.66,
Doc. 16, October 3, 1985, Chapter II, para. 92, annex 5 to the merits report, available at:
http://www.CIDH.org/countryrep/Guatemala85sp/indice.htm. Also, according to the CEH, on February 2, 1985, the
Head of State at the time “accused the members of the GAM of being managed by subversives and threatened to
take reprisals. When a journalist asked him against whom these would be taken, he answered: “you will know
them when you see them,” La Palabra, March 22, 1985, p. 15”. CEH, supra, volume IV, p. 236, note 553.
387
Cf. IACHR, Third Report on the Situation of Human Rights in Guatemala, 1985, supra, Chapter II, paras.
93, 95 and 96.
388
Cf. CEH, supra, volume IV, pp. 99 and 237, paras. 4122 and 4532.
- 108 -
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents