268.
The Commission and the representatives indicated that, in this case, the State had
violated the right of access to information, presumably established in Articles 13 and 23 305
of the Convention, to the detriment of the next of kin of the disappeared victims and of the
next of kin Rudy Gustavo Figueroa Muñoz, owing, inter alia, to: (i) the refusal of the military
authorities to provide information to the CEH; (ii) the concealment of information by the
State, and (iii) the refusal of the Ministry of Defense to provide information to the Public
Prosecution Service in the context of the criminal investigation in this case. Based on these
facts, the representatives also argued that they constitute a violation of the “autonomous
right to the truth” of the next of kin of the disappeared persons, established in Articles 8, 13
and 25 of the Convention. The State accepted fully the violation of Article 23 and partially
the violation of Article 13 of the Convention, based on the right of access to information on
the grounds that “the next of kin have not had information on the whereabouts of the
victims,” but the State “ha[d] taken some measures to ensure access to information.” In
addition, the State contested the alleged violation of the right to know the truth of the next
of kin, considering that “it is not contained, as such, in the [American Convention]” (supra
para. 17).
269. Regarding the alleged violation of the right of access to information, the Court
observes that, unlike other cases heard by this Court,306 in the instant case, this alleged
violation is not related to a specific request for information address by the presumed victims
to the State authorities in order to obtain this information. The Commission and the
representatives are asking the Court to consider that the refusal of the Ministry of Defense
to provide information, following the requests for information by extrajudicial and judicial
bodies responsible for clarifying the facts, also constitutes a violation of the right of access
to information of the next of kin of the victims of the said acts. In this regard, the Court
considers that this failure of the Ministry of Defense to collaborate with the CEH and the
authorities responsible for the investigation has been an obstacle to the elucidation of the
facts of this case and it has been assessed as such in this judgment, when ruling on the
investigations into the forced disappearances and death of Rudy Gustavo Figueroa Muñoz as
well as the consequent violations of Articles 8(1) and 25(1) of the American Convention
(supra paras. 248 to 252) and in the analysis of the right to personal integrity of the next of
kin (infra. paras. 295 to 302). Therefore, the Court considers that it is not incumbent on it
to make an independent analysis of the said refusals of information in order to determine
whether Article 13 or, if applicable, Article 23 of the Convention, has been violated to the
detriment of the next of kin of the disappeared victims and of the next of kin of Rudy
Gustavo Figueroa Muñoz.
305
Article 23 of the American Convention establishes that: “1. Every citizen shall enjoy the following rights and
opportunities: (a) to take part in the conduct of public affairs, directly or through freely chosen representatives; (b) to
vote and to be elected in genuine periodic elections, which shall be by universal and equal suffrage and by secret ballot
that guarantees the free expression of the will of the voters, and (c) to have access, under general conditions of
equality, to the public service of his country. 2. The law may regulate the exercise of the rights and opportunities
referred to in the preceding paragraph only on the basis of age, nationality, residence, language, education, civil and
mental capacity, or sentencing by a competent court in criminal proceedings.”
306
In the Case of Claude Reyes et al. v. Chile, the violation of the right of Access to information was related
to the refusal of a request for information made to the Foreign Investment Committee; while in the Case of Gomes
Lund et al. (Guerrilha do Araguaia) v. Brazil, the Court was required to rule on the violation of the right of Access
to information in the context of “a civil action against the Federal State” where “the Union [was asked] to provide
information on the burial of the next of kin, so that death certificates could be issued, the remains could be
transferred, and for a copy of the official report of the War Ministry of January 5, 1975 on the military operations to
combat the guerrilla fighters in Araguaia (Guerrilha do Araguaia).” Cf. Case of Claude Reyes et al. v. Chile. Merits,
reparations and costs. Judgment of September 19, 2006. Series C No. 151, paras. 57.13, 99 and 103, and Case of
Gomes Lund et al. (Guerrilha do Araguaia) v. Brazil. Preliminary objections, merits, reparations and costs.
Judgment of November 24, 2010. Series C No. 219, para. 188.
- 91 -
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents