270. The Court will also rule on the alleged violation of the right to know the truth of the
next of kin of the disappeared victims and of Rudy Gustavo Figueroa Muñoz in Chapter VIII3 infra.
II. Obligation to investigate the alleged detention and torture of Wendy and
Igor Santizo Méndez
A. Position of the Inter-American Commission and arguments of the parties
271. The Commission considered that the State had failed to comply with its obligation to
ensure the rights to personal liberty and to protection of the honor of Wendy Santizo
Méndez by conducting a serious and effective investigation into the alleged torture and
detention suffered by this victim, which it should have initiated ex officio following the
complaint concerning the facts. The Commission also indicated that the absence of such an
investigation also violated Articles 8 and 25 of the American Convention, in relation to
Articles 1(1) and 2 of this treaty, and Article 7 of the Convention of Belém do Pará and
Articles 1, 6 and 8 of the Inter-American Convention against Torture, to the detriment of
Wendy Santizo Méndez and her next of kin. The representatives indicated that the State
“ha[d] failed to comply with its obligation to provide victimological care [to Wendy Santizo
Méndez] and to investigate these events seriously and effectively.” Thus, they noted that
the State had the obligation to investigate these facts as of the time it accepted the Court’s
jurisdiction; consequently, by failing to do so, it had violated Article 19 of the Convention.
In addition, the Court recalls that the State expressed its partial acknowledgement of the
violations indicated by the Commission with regard to Wendy Santizo Méndez, in relation to
the events that occurred after Guatemala’s acceptance of the Court’s jurisdiction (supra
para. 17(c) and 26).
B. Considerations of the Court
272. The Court recalls that, in this case, the alleged detention and rape of Wendy Santizo
Méndez do not form part of the facts submitted to the Court (supra paras. 3 and 25).
Therefore, the Court cannot rule on the substantive rights established in Articles 5, 7 and
11307 of the American Convention. Consequently, this chapter will examine the failure to
investigate the alleged detention, rape and torture of Wendy Santizo Méndez, as well as the
alleged detention and torture of Igor Santizo Méndez, as of March 9, 1987.
273. In previous cases, the Court has recognized the necessary relationship between the
general obligation of protection indicated in Article 1(1) of the Convention and the specific
rights protected by this instrument.308 Given that this obligation of guarantee is linked to
specific rights, it can be fulfilled in different ways, depending on the right that the State has
the obligation to guarantee and the particular characteristics of the case.309 In this regard,
the Court considers it necessary to take into account that the alleged facts that should be
investigated include a presumed rape, allegedly committed by a State agent against a nine-
307
Article 11 of the American Convention establishes that: “1. Everyone has the right to have his honor
respected and his dignity recognized. 2. No one may be the object of arbitrary or abusive interference with his private
life, his family, his home, or his correspondence, or of unlawful attacks on his honor or reputation. 3. Everyone has the
right to the protection of the law against such interference or attacks.”
308
Cf. Case of Vargas Areco v. Paraguay, supra, para. 73, and Case of Garibaldi v. Brazil. Preliminary
objections, merits, reparations and costs. Judgment of September 23, 2009. Series C No. 203, para. 111.
309
Cf. Case of Vargas Areco v. Paraguay, supra, para. 73, and Case of Garibaldi v. Brazil, supra, para. 111.
- 92 -
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents