28 4) Benjamín Eduardo Zerpa-Rodríguez (victim).- He was 20 years old at the time of death.18 His mother is María Rosenda Rodríguez-Pérez.19 His brother is Luis Alfredo Zerpa20 and his sisters are Noris Margarita ZerpaRodríguez,21 Garciela Zerpa-Rodríguez22 and Maria Auxiliadora ZerpaRodríguez.23 His common law spouse is Yonary Trujillo,24 and Benjahirin Nazareth Trujillo25 is his daughter. 5) Carlos Enrique Serrano (victim). The Court has no information regarding his age at the time of death. 6) César Gregorio Guzmán (victim).- He was 20 years old at the time of death.26 7) Charly Gustavo Paiva-Reyes27 (victim).- He was 21 years old at the time of death.28 8) Deyvis Armando Flores-Velásquez (victim).- He was 25 years old at the time of death.29 9) Edgar José Peña-Marín (victim).- He was 24 years old at the time of death.30 His mother is Inocenta del Valle-Marín.31 His sisters are Doris Isabel 18 Cf. brief of requests, arguments and evidence filed by the representatives (record of the merits, reparations and costs, Volume I, Page 311). 19 Cf. copy of the birth record (record of Appendixes to the brief of requests, arguments and evidence filed by the victims’ representatives, page 2715). 20 Cf. copy of the birth record (record of the merits, reparations and costs, Volume III, pages 922 and 923). 21 Cf. copy of the birth record (record of the merits, reparations and costs, Volume III, page 924). 22 Cf. copy of the birth record (record of the merits, reparations and costs, Volume III, page 925). 23 Cf. copy of the birth record (record of the merits, reparations and costs, Volume III, page 926). 24 Cf. affidavit of Luz Victoria Chávez-Flores and Tito Antonio Guerrero, dated June 20, 2006 (record of the merits, reparations and costs, Volume III, pages 989 and 990) 25 Cf. affidavit of Luz Victoria Chávez-Flores and Tito Antonio Guerrero, dated June 20, 2006, supra note 24. 26 Cf. Tisibay Guzmán’s witness statement, record of the investigation of the Tribunal Vigésimo noveno de Primera Instancia Penal (29th Criminal Trial Court), (record of Appendixes to the application filed by the Commission, Appendix 12, Volume 3, page 1067) 27 According to the application, the victim’s name is Carlos Gustavo Reyes. However, the Court will take into account the copy of the death record, according to which the victim’s name is Charly Gustavo Paiva Reyes (record of the merits, reparations and costs, Volume II, page 410) 28 Cf. copy of the death record (record of the merits, reparations and costs, Volume II, page 410) 29 Cf. closing written arguments filed by the victims' representatives (record of the merits, reparations and costs, Volume III, page 834) 30 Cf. brief of requests, arguments and evidence filed by the representatives (record of the merits, reparations and costs, Volume I, page 309), and Appendixes to the initial petition before the InterAmerican Commission (record of the process before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, page 2006) 31 Cf. copy of the birth record (record of Appendixes to the brief of requests, arguments and evidence filed by the victims’ representatives, page 2696)