TO TERMINATE the functions of the judges of the Supreme Court of Justice and their respective
deputy judges, who failed to resign from office in January 2003, as provided for in Transitory
Provision 25 of the current Constitution; and, TO APPOINT in their place, the jurists named
below, who shall take the oath of office before the Second Vice President of the National
Congress, shall not be subject to fixed terms for the duration of their office, and shall be subject
to termination on the grounds prescribed by the Constitution and by law: […]
Within a period not exceeding fifteen days, the National Council of the Judiciary shall be
restructured and shall submit, to the National Congress, shortlists of three names for the election
of the Minister Prosecutor General of the Nation, the Superior Courts of Justice and the provincial
prosecutors.
This resolution shall enter into force immediately, regardless of its publication in the Official
Record. 131
85.
The resolution to dismiss all the judges was approved by a total of fifty-two (52)
votes in favor and three (3) votes against. 132 Forty (40) congressmen present in the
chamber decided “not to vote.” 133
86.
That same resolution also appointed the new judges of the Supreme Court of Justice.
The new appointees included four judges who formed part of the former Court, namely,
Messrs. Vergara Acosta, Guerrero Armijos, Jaramillo Arízaga and Bermeo Castillo. 134Judge
Bermeo Castillo did not accept this new appointment. 135
87.
Immediately after adopting the resolution, and without being included in the agenda,
a motion for constitutional reform was presented so that Congress would regain its
jurisdiction to impeach members of the Supreme Court of Justice. 136Said motion was
approved with thirty-four votes in favor. 137 The Congress discussed the third and last point
of the agenda, concerning the Organic Law of Elections. 138 The session ended at 00h 40
minutes. 139
88.
Following the issuance of this Resolution, the National Government “admitted that
the new Supreme Court justices would discharge their duties on a temporary basis, until the
131
Resolution 181 of December 8, 2004 (File of attachments to the report, volume I, page 206).
132
Cf. Record 24-001 of December 8, 2004 (File of attachments to the report, volume II, pages 338 to 484);
Press report “Congress restructures the Court” on December 9, 2004 (File of attachments to the answer brief,
volume I, page 3179); Press report in the daily “El Universo” entitled “Constitutional matters” of December 26,
2004 (File of attachments to the report, volume III, page 724), and Press report in the daily “El Comercio”
entitled “Majority dismisses the Court” (File of attachments to the report, volume II, page 557).
133
Record 24-001 of December 8, 2004 (File of attachments to the report, volume II, page 455 to 464).
134
Resolution no. R-25-181 of December 8, 2004 (File of attachments to the report, volume I, page 206).
These judges were selected by the National Congress on October 2, 1997 from a list drawn up by the Qualifying
Committee on October 1, 1997 (File of attachments to the report, volume I, page 105).
135
Mr. Bermeo Castillo explained that he had declined the new appointment because he considered that “the
Constitution ha[d] been […] repeatedly and reiteratedly violated by Congress, […] which had granted itself
absolutely non-existent powers, such as appointing a Supreme Court, after having dismissed, in an arbitrary
manner, the previous one.” Statement of Mr. Bermeo Castillo on November 14, 2011 (File of attachments to the
brief of pleadings and motions, volume I, pages 2369 and 2370), and press report entitled “Bermeo resigns and
denounces Parliament” from “El Comercio” newspaper, December 14, 2004 (File of attachments to the Merits
Report, volume II, page 558).
136
Cf. Record 24-001 of December 8, 2004 (File of attachments to the report, volume II, page 465).
137
Cf. Record 24-001 of December 8, 2004 (File of attachments to the report, volume II, page 476).
138
Cf. Record 24-001 of December 8, 2004 (File of attachments to the report, volume II, page 476).
139
Cf. Record 24-001 of December 8, 2004 (File of attachments to the report, volume II, page 289).
30