before this contentious proceedings were completed. Nevertheless, in his pleadings and
motions brief, he was able to describe his claims for costs and expenses.
371. Furthermore, the Court observes that representative Trejos presented expense
vouchers for US$1,376.96. 519 With his final arguments, representative May provided
invoices corresponding to five affidavits for a total of US$2,500.00 dollars, without
indicating why the cost of each notarial service had been calculated at US$500.00. In
addition, in his final arguments, representative May requested the same amount that
representative Trejos had asked for in his pleadings and motions brief, without clarifying
whether these were two autonomous requests, or else, which part of the latter request
corresponded to fees for Mr. Trejos and which part to fees for Mr. May. For his part,
representative Molina provided expense vouchers for the sum of US$9,243.00, which
corresponds mostly to the partial calculation of some professional services. 520
372.
The Court observes that the case file does not contain any supporting evidence to
justify the sums that the representatives are requesting for professional fees and services.
Indeed, the amounts requested for fees were not accompanied by specific proof of their
reasonableness and scope. 521
373. Therefore, the Court establishes, in equity, the sum of US$10,000.00 (ten thousand
United States dollars) for costs and expenses in favor of representative Gerardo Trejos,
which must be paid directly to his heirs, in keeping with the applicable domestic law.
Furthermore, the Court establishes, in equity, the sum of US$2,000.00 (two thousand
United States dollars) for costs and expenses in favor of representative May, and the sum of
US$3,000 (three thousand United States dollars) for costs and expenses in favor of
representative Molina.
E)
Method of complying with the payments ordered
374. The State must make the payments of the compensation for pecuniary and nonpecuniary damage and reimbursement of costs and expenses established in this Judgment
directly to the persons indicated herein, within one year of notification of this Judgment, in
the terms of the following paragraphs. If the beneficiaries are deceased or die before they
receive the respective compensation, this shall be delivered directly to their heirs, in
accordance with the applicable domestic law.
375. The State must comply with the pecuniary obligations by payment in United States
dollars or the equivalent in local currency, using the exchange rate in effect on the New
York Stock Exchange, United States of America, on the day before the payment.
519
In his pleadings and motions brief, representative Trejos presented as expenses during the proceedings:
(i) the invoice for the purchase of a plane ticket in the name of Andrea Bianchi (US$439.72); (ii) the invoice for the
purchase of a plane ticket in the name of Gerardo Trejos Salas (US$468.62), and (iii) the invoice for the purchase
of a plane ticket in the name of Gloria Mazariegos (US$468.62),totaling US$1,376.96 (file of annexes to the
pleadings and motions brief, volume I, folios 4071 and 4072).
520
In his pleadings and motions brief, representative Boris Molina Acevedo presented as expenses during the
proceedings: (i) invoice for professional services issued to María Lorna Ballestero Muñóz por US$6,000.00; (ii)
receipt of payment for professional services to Gabriela Darsié and Enrique Madrigal for US$1,375, (iii) receipt for
payment of professional services for advice and assistance provided by William Vega for US$ 1,600, and (iv) and
for photocopies and administrative expenses 131,850 colones (file of annexes to the pleadings and motions brief,
volume VI, folios 6537 a 6364).
521
Cf. Case of Chitay Nech et al. v. Guatemala. Preliminary objections, merits, reparations and costs.
Judgment of May 25, 2010. Series C No. 212, para. 287