lack of hygiene, discontent, resentment [and] conflicts.”22 In addition, the electrical,
drinking water, sanitation, and other facilities had collapsed. According to the information
provided by the State, the Honduran prison system is experiencing a “prison emergency.”23
26.
These problems had become worse owing to the implementation of the penal reforms
adopted by the State under the “zero tolerance” policy that sought to eradicate the maras24
and gangs in order to control the violence. These measures included the reform, by Decree
No. 117-2003 adopted in August 2003, of the definition of the offense of unlawful
association established in article 332 of the Criminal Code, increasing the punishments for
this offense and including in the text an explicit mention of the maras as a form of unlawful
association.25
27.
Following this reform, detentions based on suspicion, together with mass arrests
based on the appearance of the individual and without a warrant from a competent
authority became a common practice of the police.26
28.
The foregoing resulted in an increase in the levels of overpopulation in the prisons
and accentuated the structural problems that existed throughout the prison system, but
particularly in those centers for individuals accused of belonging to the “maras.” At the time
of the facts, the country’s 24 prisons had a total capacity of 8,280 places. However, in
2004, the prison population was 10,931 and, in 2008, this increased to 11,723.27
22
Cf. Informe sobre la situación del sistema penitenciario en Honduras [Report on the situation of the prison
system in Honduras] issued by the Inter-institutional Prison Reform Commission (file of attachments to the merits
report, attachment 57, folio 759). See also: National Human Rights Commission of Honduras, Annual Report 2003,
Chapter II: Security and Justice (file of attachments to the merits report, attachment 66, folio 946); United Nations
Human Rights Committee, Concluding observations with regard to Honduras, December 13, 2006,
CCPR/C/HND/CO/1; United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detentions, Report on the visit to Honduras,
December 1, 2006, A/HRC/4/440/Add.4.
23
Cf. Friendly settlement agreement, supra note 15.
24
According the OAS Public Security Department, the maras are transnational gangs that began to take
shape in the Central American region at the beginning of the 1990s influenced by the deportation of young people
from the United States. (“Definition and Categorization of Gangs,” Appendix IV, Report: El Salvador. Department of
Public Security, OAS, Washington, D.C., 2007). In addition, according to the United Nations definition “the maras
are organizations composed of adolescents and young adults of both sexes who develop ties of solidarity and
identification among themselves and fight for the territorial control.” (U.N., Economic Commission for Latin
American and the Caribbean (ECLAC), Seguridad ciudadana y violencia en América Latina: diagnóstico y políticas
en los años noventa, 1999).
25
The relevant part of this norm establishes: “The National Congress […] Decrees: Article 1. To amend
article 332 of the Penal Code, contained in Decree No. 144-83 of August 23, 1983, which should read as follows:
Article 332. Unlawful Association: The heads or ringleaders of maras, gangs, and other groups that associate with
the permanent purpose of executing any act that constitutes an offense shall be sanctioned with the punishment of
nine to twelve years’ imprisonment and a fine of 10,000.00 to 200,000.00 Lempiras. The other members of the
said unlawful associations shall be sanctioned with the same punishment of imprisonment established in the
preceding paragraph, reduced by one-third. The heads or ringleaders are those who are prominent or identify
themselves as such, and whose decisions influence the intentions and actions of the group” (merits report, folio
43).
26
Cf. U.N., Human Rights Committee, Concluding observations, supra note 22, and Mano Suave and Mano
Dura en Honduras: presentation by Tomás Andino Mencia during the First Central American Congress on Youth,
Security and Justice. Antigua, Guatemala, March 15 and 16, 2008 (file of attachments to the merits report,
attachment 58, folios 802 and 803).
27
Cf. U.N., Committee against Torture. Initial periodic report of Honduras, September 9, 2008. UN Doc.
CAT/C/HND/1., para. 223.
11