CEH was established in order “[t]o clarify [...] the human rights violations and the acts of
violence that have caused suffering to the Guatemalan people,” and which were related to
the armed conflict.348 In addition, under the National Reconciliation Act of December 27,
1996, “the Historical Clarification Commission [...] was charged with designing the
mechanisms for making it possible to know and recognize the historical truth about the
period of internal armed conflict in order to prevent a repetition of such events.” To this
end, it was established that “the State bodies or entities must provide the Commission with
any support it may require.”349
296. Despite this mandate and the provisions for collaboration, the Court observes that, in
its report, the CEH itself "characterized the collaboration provided by the National Army as
unreliable and unsatisfactory.” It indicated that "[w]hile the Commission was carrying out
its work, the Executive – through various agencies, including the National Army and the
Private Secretariat of the President of the Republic – gave different reasons for not handing
over the documents required by the CEH. Initially, it indicated that the documents were
subject to constitutional confidentiality; subsequently, […] it indicated that the documents
requested never existed or had been lost or destroyed. However, the Commission ha[d]
proved that some of the documents whose existence ha[d] repeatedly been denied by the
Executive did exist and were archived on the premises of the National Army.”350 Regarding
the latter, the Court underlines that the Ministry of Defense denied to the CEH the existence
of documents351 such as the Diario Militar, which appeared through unofficial channels three
months after the said Commission had published its final report (supra para. 59).
297. According to the Historical Clarification Commission, this lack of information had an
adverse impact on compliance with its mandate, and explained why it was unable, inter alia,
to determine the precise chain of command in relation to the forced disappearances
committed during the conflict (supra para. 58). Furthermore, the Court takes note of the
testimony of expert witness Valencia Villa, who worked with the CEH, when she indicated
that, if the said Commission "had been able to access all the military documents requested,
it is certain that […] many undecided cases would have been clarified.”352
298. Bearing in mind that the specific facts of this case took place in the context of a noninternational armed conflict, the elucidation of the truth of what happened acquires
particular relevance. The Court considers it pertinent to reiterate, as it has in other cases,
that States may establish truth commissions that contribute to constructing and preserving
the historical memory, clarifying facts, and determining institutional, social and political
peace by political means.” In addition, it integrated the other agreements signed within the framework of the peace
negotiations, which “come into official and full force on signature of [the said] Agreement.”
348
This Commission was established by the Agreement on the establishment of the Commission for the
Historical Clarification of the Human Rights Violations and the Acts of Violence that have caused suffering to the
Guatemalan population, signed in Oslo, on June 23, 1994, establishing the element indicated supra as one of the
main objectives of its mandate.
349
Cf. Decree No. 145-1996 – Law of National Reconciliation, December 27, 1996, art. 10 (file of annexes to
the pleadings and motions brief, tome IV, annex A55, folio 10486).
350
Cf. CEH, supra, para. 93. p. 50.
351
The CEH requested and was not given, inter alia, information on: "[r]eports and logs of daily operations
prior to 1988" of the Army, and "[t]he situation assessments, operational plans, orders of operations, operation
reports and daily operations of the Staff of the President between 1960 and 1996, as well as a general list of the
operations conducted in their area of responsibility and the reports on them.” Cf. CEH Communication to the
President of the Republic of March 24, 1998, p. 158-166.
352
Affidavit made by expert witness Alejandro Valencia Villa, supra, folio 13291.
- 101 -
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos