67
Resende de Souza Nazareth, Helenoira Resende de Souza Nazareth, Wladmir
Neves da Rocha Castiglia, Laura Petit da Silva, Clovis Petit de Oliveira, Lorena
Moroni Barroso, Breno Moroni Girão, Ciro Moroni Girão, Sônia Maria Haas,
Elizabeth Silveira e Silva, Luiz Carlos Silveira e Silva, Luiz Paulo Silveira e Silva,
Maristella Nurchis, and Valeria Costa Couto.
181. On the other hand, the Inter-American Court has information that 24
family members indicated as alleged victims passed away prior to December 10,
1998. Regarding these persons, the Court will not declare State responsibility
given the rule of jurisdiction ratione temporis.255 In addition, the Court has
information that another 38 family members passed away, even though, from the
body of evidence, the respective dates in which the deaths occurred cannot be
concluded.256 In regard to said persons, the Court will allow their next of kin or
their legal representatives to present to the Court, in a period of six months, as
of the date of notification of the present Judgment, the documentation that
evinces the date of death is subsequent to December 10, 1998 in order to
confirm their nature as victims in the present case, pursuant to the
abovementioned criteria.
182. Lastly, the Court will refer, as it has done in a constant manner, to the
guidelines that the investigations of the State should follow, in the corresponding
subsection on the obligation to investigate in the Chapter regarding reparations in
the present Judgment. In regard to the alleged non-compliance with Articles 1, 6,
and 8 of the Inter-American Convention to Prevent and Punish Torture argued by
the representatives, the Court deems that it is not necessary to rule on these
allegations given that they refer to the same facts that have been analyzed under
other conventional obligations.
255
Cf. Case of the Serrano-Cruz Sisters v. El Salvador. Merits, Reparations, and Costs. Judgment
of 1 de marzo de 2005. Series C No. 120, para. 144. According to the information provided by the
Commission and the representatives, the next of kin whom passed away prior to Brazil’s
acknowledgment of the Courts jurisdiction, are the following: Adriano Fonseca (father, 1984), Maria
Jardilina da Costa (mother, 1993), Benedita de Araújo Ribas (mother, 1995), Walter Sheiba Pinto
Ribas (father, 1996), José Ferreira de Souza (father, in 1980’s), Irene Guedes Corrêa (mother, 1986),
Edgar Corrêa (father, 1993), Antonio Olímpio Maria (father, 1980), Euthália Resende de Souza
Nazareth (mother, 1996), Adalberto de Assis Nazareth (father, 1965), Idalisio Soares Aranha (father,
1964), José Bernardino da Silva Júnior (father, 1949), Cyrene Moroni Barroso (mother, 1992),
Benigno Girão Barroso (father, 1995), Ildefonso Haas (father, 1989), Adaíde Toledo de Oliveira
(mother, 1992), José Sebastião de Oliveira (father, 1970), Jovina Ferreira (mother, 1979), Lilita
Silveira and Silva (mother, 1993), René de Oliveira and Silva (father, 1986), Silvio Marques Camilo
(father, 1964), Francisco de Assis Batista (father, 1970), Edwin da Costa (father, 1997), and
Heleneide Resende de Souza Nazareth (sister, years 1980).
256
It involves Gerson da Silva Teixeira (father), Raimundo de Castro Sobrinho (father), Helena
Almochdice Valadão (mother) and Altivo Valadão de Andrade (father), Gessiner Farias (father), Eloá
Cunha Brum (mother) and Lino Brum (father), Maria de Lourdes Oliveira (mother) and Arédio Oliveira
(father), Hilda Quaresma Saraiva (mother) and Dário Saraiva Leão (father), América Ribeiro Callado
(mother) and Consueto Callado (father), Francisca das Chagas Pereira (mother) and Carlos Gentil
Pereira (father), João Carlos Lund (father), Ermelinda Mazzaferro Bronca (mother) and Huberto Atteo
Bronca (father), Anita Lima Piauhy Dourado (mother) and Pedro Piauhy Dourado (father), Karitza
Lemos da Silva (mother) and Norival Euphorosino da Silva (father), Luigi Castiglia (father), José
Augusto de Souza (father), Joana Vieira de Almeida (esposa), Rosalina Carvalho Nurchis (mother) and
José Francisco Nurchis (father), Helena Pereira dos Santos (mother) and Pedro Francisco dos Santos
(father), Antonia Rivelino Momente (mother) and Álvaro Momente (father), Rita Orlando dos Santos
(mother) and José Orlando da Costa (father), Geny de Carvalho Troiano (mother) and Rodolfo Troiano
(father), Lindaura Correia de Souza (mother) and Rosalvo Cipriano (father), and Arnobio Santos
Coqueiro (father).
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos