84
in the alleged non-existence of said information, and then, in the alleged loss of
the purpose of said action given the enactment of Law No. 9.140/95.
227. Given the lack of application in the present case of laws and decrees
mentioned by the Commission and the representatives in the Ordinary Action
filed by the next of kin, the Court does not deem it necessary to carry out an
analysis of the existent regulations in Brazil on the right to access information.
Notwithstanding the aforementioned, the Court notes that the State informed on
the Draft Bill No. 5.228/09, presented by the Executive Power before the National
Congress, which would substantially reform the normative framework that
regulates this right. Said draft bill establishes, inter alia, that “access to
information necessary for the legal and administrative protection of fundamental
rights cannot be denied” and that “access to information or documents that
discuss actions that imply violations of human rights practiced by public agents or
mandates of public authorities cannot be subject to restrictions.”332 For their part,
the representatives spoke positively on the same, indicating that said draft bill “is
welcome” and that its adoption by the National Congress should be done quickly.
228. The Court values the initiative of the State to present a draft bill with the
purpose of optimizing and strengthening the normative framework of the right to
freedom of thought and expression established in Article 13 of the American
Convention in relation to the right to access public information in State custody.
The Court considers that the States, so as to appropriately guarantee right to
seek and receive public information under State control, must adopt the
necessary measures, among others, the approval of legislation wherein the
content is compatible with Article 13 of the American Convention and with the
jurisprudence of this Tribunal. Likewise, this right entails the obligation of the
State to incorporate in its legal code an effective and suitable remedy that can be
used by the citizenry and to resolve eventual controversies.
229. Of course, the right to access to public information in State custody is not
an absolute right, given that it may be subject to restrictions. Nevertheless, these
must first be previously established by law—in a formal and material sense—so
as to assure that they not be subject to the discretion of the public power.
Second, the restrictions established by law must respond to an objective allowed
in Article 13(2) of the American Convention, namely, they must be necessary to
assure “the respect for the rights and reputation of others” or “the protection of
national security, public order, or public health or morals.” The limitations
imposed must be necessary in a democratic society and oriented to satisfy an
imperative public interest. This implies that from all the possible alternatives
there must be elected those measures that restrict or interfere in the most
minimal possible manner the effective exercise of the right to seek and receive
information.333
230.
Moreover, to guarantee the full and effective exercise of this right,
it is necessary that the legislation and the State procedures are governed by the
principles of good faith and maximum disclosure, in a way that all information in
State power is presumed public and accessible, subject to a limited regime of
exceptions. Likewise, all denials of information must be motivated and founded,
332
Article 16 of Bill No. 5228/09 that regulates access to information, of May 5, 2009 (brief of
annexes to the answer to the application, tome III, annex 18, folio 366).
333
Cf. Advisory Opinion OC-5/85, supra note 294, para. 46; Case of Ricardo Canese v.
Paraguay. Merits, Reparations and Costs. Judgment of August 31, 2004. Series C No. 111, para. 96,
and Case of Palamara Iribarne v. Chile. Merits, Reparations and Costs. Judgment of November 22,
2005. Series C No. 135, para. 85.
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos