91 Soares Santana (mother) and Antonio Pereira de Santana (father), Elza da Conceição Oliveira (or Elza Conceição Bastos) (mother) and Viriato Augusto Oliveira (father), Maria Gomes dos Santos (mother), Rosa Cabello Maria (or Rosa Olímpio Cabello) (mother), Igor Grabois Olímpio363 (son), Julia Gomes Lund (mother), Carmem Navarro (mother) and Gerson Menezes Magalhães (father), Aminthas Aranha (o Aminthas Rodrigues Pereira), (mother), Julieta Petit da Silva364 (mother), Ilma Hass (mother), Osoria Calatrone (mother) and Clotildio Calatrone (father), Isaura de Souza Patricio (mother) and Joaquim Patricio (father), Elena Gibertini Castiglia (mother), Jardilina Santos Moura (mother) and Joaquim Moura Paulino (father), José Vieira de Almeida (son), Acary V. de S. Garlippe (mother), Dora Grabois (mother) and Agostim Grabois (father), Rosana Moura Momente (daughter), Maria Leonor Pereira Marques (mother), Otilia Mendes Rodrigues (mother) y Francisco Alves Rodrigues (father), Celeste Durval Cordeiro (mother) and Luiz Durval Cordeiro (father), Aidinalva Dantas Batista (mother), Elza Pereira Coqueiro (mother), Odete Afonso Costa (mother), direct family members of the disappeared or executed victims, as well as other nondirect family members, Angela Harkavy (sister), José Dalmo Ribeiro Ribas (brother), Maria Eliana de Castro Pinheiro (brother), Roberto Valadão (brother), Diva Soares Santana (sister), Getúlio Soares Santana (brother), Dilma Santana Miranda (sister), Dinorá Santana Rodrigues (sister), Dirceneide Soares Santana (sister), Terezinha Souza Amorim (sister), Aldo Creder Corrêa365 (brother), Helenalda Resende de Souza Nazareth (sister), Helenice Resende de Souza Nazareth (sister), Helenilda Resende de Souza Nazareth (sister), Helenoira Resende de Souza Nazareth (sister), Wladmir Neves da Rocha Castiglia (nephew), Laura Petit da Silva366 (sister), Clovis Petit de Oliveira367 (sister), Lorena Moroni Barroso (sister), Breno Moroni Girão (brother), Ciro Moroni Girão (brother), Sônia Maria Haas (sister), Elizabeth Silveira e Silva (sister), Luiz Carlos Silveira e Silva (brother), Luiz Paulo Silveira e Silva (brother), Maristella Nurchis (sister), and Valeria Costa Couto (sister). 244. On the other hand, regarding the 24 next of kin indicated as alleged victims whom passed away prior to December 10, 1998, the Court will not rule on the State’s responsibility due to the rule on ratione temporis jurisdiction (supra para. 181). Lastly, in regard to the 38 deceased next of kin whose dates of death have not been established, the Court has ordered that their next of kin or their legal representatives must present to the Court, in a period of six months as of notification of the present Judgment, the documentation that evinces that the date of death is subsequent to December 10, 1998, so as to confirm their condition as victims in the present case (supra para. 181). being able to recognize the signature she made in a statement made for the Inter-American Court,” (case file on the merits, tome IV, folio 1594). 363 Mr. Igor Grabois Olímpo is also the nephew and grandson, respectively, of two disappeared persons of the Guerrilha de Araguaia, Messers. André Grabois and Maurício Grabois. 364 Mrs. Julieta Petit da Silva is the mother of two disappeared persons of the Guerrilha do Araguaia, Messers. Jaime and Lúcio Petit da Silva, and of Mrs. Maria Lúcia Petit da Silva. 365 Mr. Aldo Creder Corrêa is the brother of the two disappeared persons of the Guerrilha do Araguaia, Messers. Elmo Corrêa and Maria Célia Corrêa. 366 Mrs. Laura Petit da Silva is the sister of the two disappeared persons of the Guerrilha do Araguaia, Messers. Jaime and Lúcio Petit da Silva, and of Mrs. Maria Lúcia Petit da Silva. 367 Mr. Clovis Petit da Silva is the brother of the two disappeared persons of the Guerrilha do Araguaia, Messers. Jaime and Lúcio Petit da Silva, and of Mrs. Maria Lúcia Petit da Silva.