113 4. The State violated Article 13 in relation to the obligation of non-discrimination contained in Article 1(1) of the American Convention, to the detriment of Marcel Granier, Peter Bottome, Jaime Nestares, Inés Bacalao, Eladio Lárez, Eduardo Sapene, Daniela Bergami, Miguel Ángel Rodríguez, Soraya Castellano, María Arriaga and Larissa Patiño, pursuant to paragraph 235 of this judgment. Unanimously, that 5. The State violated the right to due process established in Article 8(1) in relation to Article 1(1) of the American Convention, in the procedures for transformation of the titles and renewal of the concession, to the detriment of Marcel Granier, Peter Bottome, Jaime Nestares, Jean Nestares, Fernando Nestares, Alicia Phelps de Tovar and Francisco J. Nestares, pursuant to paragraph 253 of this judgment. Unanimously, that 6. The State violated the right to a reasonable time, established in Article 8(1) in relation to Article 1(1) of the American Convention, in the context of the administrative appeal for nullification, to the detriment of Marcel Granier, Peter Bottome, Jaime Nestares, Jean Nestares, Fernando Nestares, Alicia Phelps de Tovar, Francisco J. Nestares, Edgardo Mosca, Anani Hernández, Inés Bacalao, José Simón Escalona, Eladio Lárez, Odila Rubin, Oswaldo Quintana, Eduardo Sapene, Daniela Bergami, Isabel Valero, Miguel Ángel Rodríguez, Soraya Castellano, María Arriaga and Larissa Patiño, pursuant to paragraph 276 of this judgment. Unanimously, that 7. The State violated the right to a reasonable time, established in Article 8(1) in relation to Article 1(1) of the American Convention, in the processing of the unspecified interim measure in the context of the administrative appeal for nullification, to the detriment of Marcel Granier, Peter Bottome, Jaime Nestares, Jean Nestares, Fernando Nestares, Alicia Phelps de Tovar, Francisco J. Nestares, Edgardo Mosca, Anani Hernández, Inés Bacalao, José Simón Escalona, Eladio Lárez, Odila Rubin, Oswaldo Quintana, Eduardo Sapene, Daniela Bergami, Isabel Valero, Miguel Ángel Rodríguez, Soraya Castellano, María Arriaga and Larissa Patiño, pursuant to paragraph 287 of this judgment. Unanimously, that 8. The State violated the rights to a hearing and a reasonable time established in Article 8(1) in relation to Article 1(1) of the American Convention when processing the action on joint and separate interests to the detriment of Marcel Granier, Peter Bottome, Jaime Nestares, Jean Nestares, Fernando Nestares, Alicia Phelps de Tovar, Francisco J. Nestares, pursuant to paragraph 308 of this judgment. Unanimously, that 9. The State did not violate Article 8 in relation to Article 1(1) of the American Convention, in the context of the processing of the criminal complaint, pursuant to paragraph 295 of this judgment. Unanimously, that 10. The State did not violate the right to a simple and prompt remedy established in Article 25(1) in relation to Article 1(1) of the American Convention, in the context of the constitutional