114 amparo proceeding and the request for an injunction, pursuant to paragraphs 318 and 323 of this judgment. By five votes to two, that: 11. It has not been proved that the State violated the guarantees of independence and impartiality established in Article 8(1) in relation to Article 1(1) of the American Convention, in the context of the administrative appeal for nullification, pursuant to paragraph 278 of this judgment. By five votes to two, that: 12. It has not been proved that the State violated the guarantees of independence and impartiality established in Article 8(1) in relation to Article 1(1) of the American Convention, when processing the action on joint and separate interests, pursuant to paragraph 305 of this judgment. By five votes to two, that: 13. It has not been proved that the State violated the right to property established in Article 21 in relation to Article 1(1) of the American Convention, pursuant to paragraph 359 of this judgment. AND ESTABLISHES, Unanimously, that: 14. This judgment constitutes, per se. a form of reparation. By five votes to two, that: 15. The State shall re-establish the concession of the frequency on the electromagnetic spectrum corresponding to television channel 2 in accordance with paragraph 380 of this judgment and shall return the property that is the subject of the interim measure, pursuant to paragraph 381 of this judgment. By five votes to two, that: 16. When the RCTV concession has been re-established, the State shall, within a reasonable time, order the opening of an open, independent and transparent process to grant the frequency on the electromagnetic spectrum corresponding to television channel 2 and, to this end, shall following the procedure established in the LOTEL or the relevant domestic law in force, pursuant to paragraph 382 of this judgment. Unanimously, that: 17. The State shall, with six months of notification of this judgment, make the publications indicated in paragraph 386 of the judgment, as indicated therein. Unanimously, that: 18. The State shall take the necessary measures to ensure that all future processes to assign and renew radio and television frequencies are conducted in an open, independent and transparent manner, pursuant to paragraph 394 of this judgment.