ratified at a hearing on November 8, 2007.176 On December 13, 2007, Section Three of the Council of State approved the conciliation reached between the Nation and 19 of the 23 optional joint parties and declared the proceedings concluded in their regard; it also failed to approve the agreement with regard to the other four and ordered the procedure to continue.177 On November 29, 2008, Section Three of the Council of State declared the Nation (Ministry of Defense – Colombian Air Force) financially liable for the damage caused to the four joint parties regarding whom the proceeding had continued for the events of December 13, 1998.178 126. By resolutions 0979 of March 18, 2009,179 and 1560 of April 27, 2009,180 the Ministry of Defense paid the representative of the presumed victims a total of five thousand seven hundred and fifty-eight million, seven hundred and fifty-nine thousand and nineteen pesos and twenty cents ($5,758,759,019.20) in reparation and compensation for the events of Santo Domingo181 to 23 176 Cf. Record of November 8, 2007, Third Section, Council of State, Mario Galvis Gelves et al., proceedings No. 28259 (00-0034801) (evidence file, tome 3, folios 1044 and 1045). 177 Cf. In a decision of December 13, 2007, the Third Section of the Council of State approved the judicial conciliation between the parties, in relation to proceedings 2003-348, 2003-350, 2003-352, 2003-353, 2003-355, 2003-357, 2003-358, 2003-361, 2003-363, 2003-364, 2003-365, 2003-366, 2003-367, 2003-1265 and 2003-1267; and ordered the termination of the proceedings between the Nation and the following discretionary co-litigants: Mario Galvis Gelves, Óscar Andrés Galvis Mujica, John Mario Galvis Mujica, Luis Alberto Galvis Mujica, Nelson Enrique Galvis Mujica, Robert Yamid Galvis Mujica, Albeiro Galvis Mujica, Nelcy Moreno Lizarazo, Nidia Mayerly Carrillo Moreno, Leidy Liliana Carrillo Moreno, Deivis Daniela Moreno Lizarazo, Tulia Mora de Carrillo, Luis Enrique Carrillo Mora, Irma Nelly Carrillo Mora, Marleny Carrillo Mora, Edgar Carrillo Mora, Nelcy Carrillo Mora, Ana Mirián Durán Mora, Rosalbina Durán Mora, Graciela Durán Mora viuda de Monterrey, Marcos Neite González, Leyda Shirley Neite Méndez, Vilma Yadira Neite Méndez, Marcos Aurelio Neite Méndez, Carmen Edilia González Ravelo, Neftalí Neite González, Neila Neite González, Salomón Neite González, Amalio Neite González, Elizabeth Neite González, Jorge Henry Vanegas Ortiz, Myriam Soreira Tulivila Macualo, Jorge Mario Vanegas Tulivila, Yaritza Lisbeth Vanegas Tulivila, Edwin Fernando Vanegas Tulivila, Ludwing Vanegas Muñoz, Fredy Yovany Monoga Villamizar, María Elida Becerra Rubio, José Rafael Hernández Mujica, Diana Carolina Hernández Becerra, José Luis Hernández Becerra, Érica Yusdey Hernández Becerra, Luz Helena Hernández Becerra, Bertha Hernández Becerra, Emérita Hernández Becerra, Milciades Bonilla Ostos, Nancy Chaquira Bonilla Ávila, Jorge Eliécer Ávila, Carmen Elisa Abaunza Castillo, Sandy Yomaira Ávila Castillo, Pedro Ávila Castillo, Gladis Cecilia Ávila Castillo, Omar Ávila Castillo, Tiberio Barranco Téllez, Eliberta Bastilla, Yilmer Orledy Barranco Bastilla, Hilda Yuraine Barranco Bastilla, Edwin Fabián Barranco Bastilla, Anyi Marieth Barranco Bastilla, Gleidys Xiomara García Guevara, Alba Janeth García Guevara, Olimpo Cárdenas Castañeda, Margarita Tilano Yánez, Erinzon Olimpo Cárdenas Tilano, Wilmer Yesid Cárdenas Tilano, Orlando Castro Londoño, Inés Yurelli Bello Tilano, Angie Camila Castro Bello, Mónica Alicia Bello Tilano, Camilo Andrés Quintana Bello, Rule Constanza Bello Tilano, Deicy Damaris Cedano, Jeinny Damaris Cedano, Pablo Gesnober Cedano, Ascensión Daza Galindo, Eliud Suárez Daza, Eliécer Suárez Daza, José Alirio Suárez Daza, Wilson Suárez Daza, Nilsa Jesús Díaz Herrera, José David Rincón Díaz, Dionisio Arciniégas Velandia, Florinda Calvo Rey, Jorge Eliécer Arciniégas Calvo, Diomedes Arciniégas Calvo, Norberto Arciniégas Calvo, Olinto Arciniégas Calvo, Argemiro Arciniégas Calvo, Erlinda Arciniégas Calvo, Gladys Arciniégas Calvo, Omaira Arciniégas Calvo, Orlando Arciniégas Calvo, Luz Dary Abaunza Castillo and Yexi Coromoto Arciniégas Rangel. In addition, it did not approve the conciliation between the Nation and the following discretionary co-litigants (proceedings 2003-351, 2003-354, 2003-356 and 2003-359): Carmen Edilia González Ravelo, Neftalí Neite González, Neila Neite González, Salomón Neite González, Amalio Neite González, Elizabeth Neite González, Marcos Neite González, Romelia Neite de López, Nerys Duarte Cárdenas, Davinson Duarte Cárdenas, Andersson Duarte Cárdenas, Rafael Díaz Ramírez, Clemencia Cobos, Ana Lucía Díaz Cobos, Sonia Díaz Cobos, Giovanni Díaz Cobos, Leonel Díaz Cobos, Luz Helena Díaz Cobos, Norberto Leal, Benilda Pacheco de Leal, Rubiela Leal Pacheco, Edwin Leal Pacheco, Frady Alexi Leal Pacheco, Norelis Leal Pacheco, Lucero Talero Sánchez, Luis Eduardo Martínez Talero, Yésica Martínez Talero, Doris Adriana Martínez Talero, Excelino Martínez Rodríguez, Teodora Carreño Alarcón, Pedro Virgilio Martínez Carreño, José Vicente Martínez Carreño, Manuel Alfonso Martínez Carreño, Claudia Exelina Martínez Carreño, Ana Fidelia Martínez Carreño and María Elena Carreño and ordered the continuation of the proceeding in relation to these individuals. 178 Cf. Judgment of November 19, 2008, Third Section, Council of State, Mario Galvis Gelves et al., case file No 07001-23-31-0002000-0348-01, Councilor Rapporteur: Ramiro Saavedra Becerra (evidence file, tome 3, folios 1046 to 1127). 179 Cf. Decision 0979 of March 18, 2009, Ministry of National Defense, Legal Affairs Directorate, complying with the conciliatory agreement in favor of Mario Galvis Gelves et al. (evidence file, tome 20, folios 10690 to 10707). 180 Cf. Decision 1560 of April 27, 2009, Ministry of National Defense, Legal Affairs Directorate, complying with a Judgment in favor of Mario Gelves et al., Carmen Edilla Gonzalez Revelo et al. (evidence file, tome 20, folios 10666 to 10672). 181 Cf. Decision 0979 of 2009, March 18, 2009, Ministry of National Defense, Legal Affairs Directorate (evidence file, tome 3, folios 1129 to 1146), and Decision 1560 of April 27, 2009 Ministry of National Defense, Legal Affairs Directorate, complying with a Judgment in favor of Mario Gelves et al., Carmen Edilla Gonzalez Revelo et al. (evidence file, tome 3, folios 1147 to 1155). ‐ 35 ‐