44
victim of a break-in at his home and that Ulises Cantoral-Huamaní stated that, on that
occasion, his brother’s case file was stolen.128
183. The Court recognizes these circumstances and establishes for each of the persons
mentioned in paragraphs 181 and 182 an additional amount of US$5,000 (five thousand
United States dollars).
184. The State must pay the compensation for non pecuniary damage within one year of
notification of this judgment.
*
*
*
185. In keeping with the previous paragraphs, the compensation payments established by
the Court are as follows:
Beneficiaries
Saúl Isaac Cantoral-Huamaní
Consuelo Trinidad García-Santa Cruz
Next of kin of Saúl Cantoral-Huamaní
Pelagia Mélida Contreras-Montoya de Cantoral (wife)
Elisa Huamaní-Infanzón (mother, deceased)
Patrocinio Cantoral-Contreras (father, deceased)
Marco Antonio Cantoral-Lozano (son)
Vanessa Cantoral-Contreras (daughter)
Brenda Cantoral-Contreras (daughter)
Rony Cantoral-Contreras (son)
Juan Cantoral-Huamaní (brother)
Ulises Cantoral-Huamaní (brother)
Eloy Cantoral-Huamaní (brother)
Gertrudis Victoria Cantoral-Huamaní (sister)
Angélica Cantoral-Huamaní (sister)
Next of kin of Consuelo García-Santa Cruz
Amelia Beatriz Santa Cruz-Portocarrero (mother)
Alfonso García-Rada (father, deceased)
Rosa Amelia García-Santa Cruz (sister)
Manuel Fernando García-Santa Cruz (brother)
María Elena García-Santa Cruz (sister)
Walter Ernesto García-Santa Cruz (brother)
Mercedes Grimaneza García-Santa Cruz (sister)
Jesús Enrique García-Santa Cruz (brother)
Amount
US$ 72,500.00
US$ 68,000.00
US$ 31,000.00
US$ 20,000.00
US$ 20,000.00
US$ 20,000.00
US$ 20,000.00
US$ 20,000.00
US$ 20,000.00
US$ 5,000.00
US$10,000.00
US$ 10,000.00
US$ 10,000.00
US$ 5,000.00
US$ 21,000.00
US$ 20,000.00
US$ 5,000.00
US$ 5,000.00
US$ 5,000.00
US$ 5,000.00
US$ 5,000.00
US$ 5,000.00
186. The State must pay the compensation for non pecuniary damage directly to the
beneficiaries within one year from notification of this judgment.
C) Measure of restitution
187.
Finally, regarding the sum of US$7,500.00 (seven thousand five hundred United
States dollars) delivered by the Mining Federation to Saúl Cantoral-Huamaní, which
moments before his death, he left in the hotel where he was staying, and which was seized
and judicially deposited by the authorities investigating the case; the Court notes that it was
never restituted, but was lost or stolen while in judicial custody. This assumption is
128
Cf. testimony provided by Ulises Cantoral-Huamaní during the public hearing on January 23, 2007, before
the Inter-American Court.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents